There’s a pair of gardening gloves sitting on our coffee table, and I have absolutely no idea how they got there. They’re green, slightly faded, and covered in the sort of dirt that suggests somebody has been doing actual work. I recognized them immediately because Mrs Jenkins was wearing them last weekend when she was pulling weeds from her flowerbeds. I remember this because she waved at me while I was taking out the rubbish, and I spent an embarrassing amount of time wondering how she managed to keep her garden looking so nice when I could barely keep a houseplant alive. Anyway, those same gloves are now sitting in our living room, right beside the television remote. I don’t want to make a big deal out of it, but I think it’s fair to ask why our neighbor’s gardening equipment has taken up residence on our furniture.
Pandora is outside with Mr Whiskers, enjoying one of those rare mornings when the weather is pleasant enough to make going outdoors seem like a good idea. She’s been taking him out on his harness more often lately, although I suspect he thinks the arrangement is the other way around. John Mercer is still asleep in his bedroom, which means I’m temporarily the only responsible adult available to investigate the gloves. I pick one up and examine it. There’s a little dried mud around the fingertips, a few bits of grass caught in the stitching, and what looks suspiciously like a cat hair near the wrist. None of this proves anything, obviously, but I put the glove down carefully anyway. I’ve watched enough detective shows to know you shouldn’t go disturbing evidence without a good reason.
The strange thing is that I’ve been seeing gardening gloves everywhere lately. There was a pair beside the kitchen sink yesterday, and I’m almost certain I saw one sticking out of John’s laundry basket earlier in the week. At the time, I didn’t think much of it. People have hobbies, and gardening is probably one of the less alarming ones. But now I’m starting to wonder whether these are all the same gloves, or whether we’ve somehow become a distribution center for misplaced gardening equipment. I briefly consider asking John, but I know exactly how that conversation will go. He’ll tell me they’re gloves, I’ll explain that they’re Mrs Jenkins’ gloves, and he’ll ask whether I’ve considered returning them to Mrs Jenkins. It’s difficult to conduct a proper investigation when everyone around you insists on being practical.
I wander over to the window and look outside. Pandora is standing near the little patch of flowers by our walkway, holding Mr Whiskers’ leash while he investigates something beneath a shrub. Mrs Jenkins is beside her, pointing toward a few plants and apparently explaining something. They’ve been talking about gardening quite a bit lately, which is nice, I suppose. Pandora has taken an interest in growing flowers, and Mrs Jenkins knows more about plants than anyone I’ve ever met. Still, I can’t help noticing how comfortably they’re chatting while a pair of Mrs Jenkins’ gloves sits unexplained on our coffee table. I wonder whether Pandora borrowed them and forgot to mention it. That would be reasonable. Almost disappointingly reasonable.
John finally emerges from his bedroom looking like a man who has lost an argument with his alarm clock. He heads straight for the kitchen, starts making coffee, and doesn’t seem particularly interested when I tell him we’ve got a situation. “What kind of situation?” he asks. I point toward the living room. He walks over, looks at the gloves, and then looks at me. “Someone’s been gardening,” he says. I explain that the gloves belong to Mrs Jenkins and have been appearing in different places around the apartment. John takes a sip of coffee and considers this. “Maybe Pandora borrowed them.” I tell him that’s my leading theory, although I don’t appreciate how quickly he arrived at it. “Then ask Pandora,” he says, and returns to the kitchen. Sometimes I wonder whether John has any appreciation for the investigative process.
I decide to wait until Pandora comes inside, partly because I want to ask her about the gloves and partly because I’m curious to see whether she notices them without being prompted. In the meantime, I check the kitchen sink. There’s nothing unusual there except a sponge, two mugs, and a spoon that somebody has apparently decided doesn’t need washing yet. I glance toward John’s laundry basket, which is visible through his open bedroom door, but resist the temptation to search it. Even I recognize that rummaging through a roommate’s laundry in pursuit of a gardening glove would be difficult to justify. Instead, I return to the living room and sit opposite the coffee table, where I can keep the gloves under observation. Mr Whiskers would probably approve of this approach. He spends half his life staring at things until somebody does something interesting.
Pandora comes back a few minutes later with Mr Whiskers trotting ahead of her, looking enormously pleased with himself. She unclips his harness, hangs the leash by the door, and asks whether I want another coffee. I tell her I have a question first. She looks at me, then at the gloves on the table, and smiles. “Oh, those. I borrowed them from Mrs Jenkins yesterday.” I feel a small but undeniable sense of triumph. “I thought so,” I say. Pandora explains that Mrs Jenkins was helping her with the flowerbed and lent her the gloves because she’d forgotten to bring her own. That answers one question, but I still have several others. “Then why were they beside the kitchen sink?” I ask. “Because I washed my hands when I came inside.” Fair enough. “And why was one in John’s laundry basket?” Pandora pauses. “What?”
Before I can explain, John appears in the doorway holding a different pair of gloves. These are dark blue, considerably larger, and covered in dust rather than soil. “You mean these?” he asks. I recognize them immediately as the gloves he uses when he’s cleaning out the storage cupboard or moving boxes. Apparently, the glove I spotted in his laundry basket had nothing to do with Mrs Jenkins. I admit that this weakens my theory slightly, although I point out that we still have two pairs of gloves appearing in suspiciously convenient locations. John gives me a long look. “Hal, we have three adults living here. Sometimes we own similar objects.” I don’t think he understands how little comfort that provides.
Pandora picks up Mrs Jenkins’ gloves and starts brushing the dried dirt from the fingers. “I was going to return these today,” she says. “Mrs Jenkins told me to keep them until I finished planting.” She then explains that she’s been working on the flowers near our walkway because she wants them to look nice before the weather gets any colder. Mrs Jenkins has been giving her advice about which plants will survive and which ones will probably surrender at the first sign of frost. It’s a perfectly ordinary explanation, and I can feel my elaborate theory collapsing under the weight of common sense. Still, something bothers me. “What about Mr Whiskers?” I ask. Pandora looks down at the cat, who’s sitting beside the coffee table. “What about him?” “He’s been acting strangely around the garden.” She laughs. “He’s a cat, Hal. Everything outside is interesting to him.”
I might have left it there if Mr Whiskers hadn’t chosen that exact moment to reach up, hook one of the gloves with his paw, and pull it off the coffee table. It landed on the rug with a soft thump. He immediately grabbed it in his mouth and started dragging it toward the hallway. Pandora stared at him. John stopped drinking his coffee. I stood up so quickly that I nearly knocked my knee against the table. “There!” I announced. “That’s what I’ve been trying to tell you!” Mr Whiskers continued dragging the glove, apparently unconcerned that he’d just provided the most significant development in my investigation. He disappeared around the corner with the determination of a small animal transporting something far too large for his mouth.
We followed him into the hallway, where he was attempting to pull the glove beneath a narrow cabinet. He’d already managed to get most of it underneath, leaving only the cuff sticking out. When Pandora reached down to retrieve it, Mr Whiskers gave a little protesting chirp and tried to pull harder. John crouched beside the cabinet and peered underneath. “Well, would you look at that,” he said. He reached into the gap and pulled out a small collection of objects: a toy mouse, a crumpled receipt, a plastic bottle cap, and one of Pandora’s missing hair ties. I recognized the hair tie immediately. We’d spent part of the previous week looking for it, and Pandora had eventually assumed she’d lost it somewhere outside. Apparently, Mr Whiskers had been running a private storage operation beneath the hallway furniture.
Pandora burst out laughing. “He’s been stealing things again!” she said. John held up the glove, which was now decorated with several fresh tooth marks. “Looks like he was adding to his collection.” I stared at the little pile of household objects on the floor. Suddenly, several things made sense. Mr Whiskers hadn’t been anxiously investigating the garden. He’d been fascinated by the gloves because they smelled like dirt, grass, and all the interesting things he wasn’t allowed to roll around in. Once Pandora brought them inside, he’d apparently decided they belonged to him. The glove I’d seen beside the kitchen sink was probably the same one he’d tried to drag away before Pandora put it back. I hadn’t been tracking a conspiracy. I’d been watching a cat repeatedly attempt to steal gardening equipment.
What happened next was the part that really got me. Pandora picked up the glove and placed it on top of the hallway cabinet, safely out of reach. Mr Whiskers sat down beneath it and stared upward. When nobody moved to help him, he walked over to John, rubbed against his leg, and meowed. John ignored him. The cat then approached Pandora and tried the same thing, adding a particularly pitiful little chirp. She laughed and told him he wasn’t getting the glove back. Finally, he turned toward me. I could practically see the calculation taking place behind those green eyes. He walked over, sat directly in front of my feet, and looked up at me with the sort of expression that makes you wonder whether you’ve neglected some important responsibility.
“Don’t even think about it,” I told him. He blinked slowly. I looked toward the cabinet, then back at the cat. He glanced up at the glove and meowed again. John started laughing. “He’s asking you to get it for him.” I informed him that I wasn’t falling for such an obvious manipulation. Mr Whiskers responded by placing one white paw gently on my shoe. Pandora had to lean against the wall because she was laughing so hard. I stood there for a moment, trying to maintain my dignity while a ten-pound cat negotiated with me over stolen gardening equipment. Eventually, I bent down and scratched him behind the ears. He immediately stopped looking at me and returned his attention to the glove. Apparently, affection was not an acceptable substitute.
We returned Mrs Jenkins’ gloves later that afternoon, after Pandora finished planting the last few flowers. Mrs Jenkins was delighted to hear about Mr Whiskers’ attempted theft and said she wasn’t surprised. Apparently, he’d tried to steal one of her gloves before while she was working in the garden, and she’d assumed he was simply playing. She offered to give him an old glove that had lost its partner, but Pandora politely declined. We already had enough trouble keeping him from collecting things around the apartment. Mrs Jenkins laughed and suggested that perhaps he needed his own gardening equipment. I considered pointing out that this would only encourage him, but I suspected nobody was particularly interested in my opinion at that moment.
By evening, the gloves were back with their rightful owner, the flowers were planted, and Mr Whiskers’ collection had been cleared out from beneath the cabinet. I felt reasonably satisfied that the mystery had been solved, even if the explanation was considerably less dramatic than I’d anticipated. John spent the rest of the day making jokes about my investigation, and Pandora kept reminding me that I’d nearly accused an innocent pair of gardening gloves of participating in a neighborhood conspiracy. I told them both that I’d simply been paying attention to unusual details. That’s what observant people do. They notice things that others overlook, even if those things occasionally turn out to involve a cat with questionable property rights.
Then, just before bed, I walked into the living room and found Mr Whiskers dragging one of John’s blue work gloves across the rug. He froze when he saw me, the glove hanging from his mouth. For several seconds, neither of us moved. I pointed toward the hallway and said, “Absolutely not.” He stared at me, considered his options, and continued walking as though I hadn’t spoken. I watched him disappear around the corner, presumably heading for the space beneath the cabinet.
I could have stopped him. I probably should have stopped him. Instead, I went to find John and told him his gloves were being stolen.
He looked up from his phone and said, “Did you catch the suspect?”
“Red-handed,” I replied.
John glanced toward the hallway. “Orange-pawed, more like.”
I hate that he came up with that before I did.
