Author: Hal

I’m making breakfast when I notice Karen standing unusually still beside the kitchen counter, staring at the floor. She stopped by a few minutes ago to return something Pandora lent her, and until now the visit has been completely ordinary. Pandora is pouring coffee, I’m attempting to prevent eggs from becoming permanently attached to the frying pan, and Mr Whiskers is somewhere beneath the kitchen table. At first I assume Karen is waiting for me to move so she can reach the coffee, but then I realize she isn’t looking at me. She’s looking underneath the table with an expression I can’t quite identify. It’s not fear exactly. It’s more concentrated than that, the expression of somebody who has noticed something and hasn’t yet decided whether to mention it. I follow her eyes and find Mr Whiskers crouched behind one of the chairs, completely still, which is unusual by itself because breakfast normally transforms him into a highly motivated kitchen inspector. Anything involving eggs, butter, cheese, milk, or the possibility that something might fall onto the floor receives his immediate supervision. This morning he’s tucked himself behind a chair with his front paws underneath him, staring back at Karen while Karen stares at him. Neither seems willing to make the first move. I turn down the heat beneath the eggs and ask, “What?” Karen looks at me as though I’ve interrupted something and asks, “What what?” I point toward Mr Whiskers and tell her she’s staring at him. She looks back underneath the table and says, “He’s staring at me.” That’s technically true, but it doesn’t explain why she was staring first.

Pandora hands Karen a cup of coffee and doesn’t seem remotely concerned, which immediately makes me wonder whether I’m the only person recognizing how unusual this is. I ask whether Mr Whiskers has been acting strangely this morning, and Pandora says no. Karen doesn’t answer. She’s still watching him, and that’s what bothers me. If Karen had simply said the cat was behaving strangely, I probably would have accepted that, but instead she has the unmistakable look of someone processing information. I know that look because I’ve worn it myself many times, although Pandora insists that when I do it, it usually means I’m about to make everyone’s day considerably more complicated. I ask Karen whether she sees something. She hesitates for perhaps half a second before saying, “Maybe,” which is not an acceptable answer when somebody is staring underneath your kitchen table. Before I can ask what she means, there’s a knock at the door and Pandora goes to answer it. John Mercer appears a moment later, having stopped by on his way somewhere else, and walks into the kitchen whistling like a man entering a room where absolutely nothing unusual is happening. He says good morning to Karen, says good morning to me, and reaches for the coffee while Karen answers him without taking her attention completely away from Mr Whiskers. John doesn’t notice. Or at least he appears not to notice. I watch the two of them for a moment and begin wondering whether I’m observing two completely different levels of awareness. Karen sees something. I see that Karen sees something. John sees coffee.

I ask John whether he notices anything unusual, and he immediately looks around the kitchen. Pandora, without even turning around, says, “Don’t.” John stops looking and asks what he’s supposed to be noticing. I tell him I’m not going to influence his observations by specifying the subject, and he points out that asking whether he notices something unusual has already influenced his observations. That’s annoyingly sophisticated for this early in the morning, so I tell him to forget I asked. He says that’s going to be difficult now, pours himself coffee, and contributes nothing further to the investigation. Meanwhile Karen bends slightly to get a better look underneath the table, and Mr Whiskers still doesn’t move. I crouch beside her and look beneath the table from her angle, but everything appears perfectly normal. Orange fur, white chest, green eyes, tail curled beside him, no obvious injury and no suspicious object nearby. There’s nothing underneath the table except the cat, chair legs, and a crumb I make a mental note to remove before Pandora notices it. I ask Karen what she’s looking at. “I’m not sure yet,” she says. I turn toward her because the word yet changes the situation considerably. Karen gives me a slightly embarrassed smile and explains that she thought she noticed something when she came in. When I ask what, she tells me she’ll tell me if she’s right.

Karen now has a hypothesis. I don’t know what the hypothesis is, which means I’m operating at an informational disadvantage inside my own kitchen. Pandora puts a plate in front of me and tells me to eat breakfast before it gets cold, but it’s difficult to focus on eggs when another person has identified a potentially significant anomaly approximately four feet away and refuses to disclose its nature. I watch Mr Whiskers while I eat. He remains underneath the table. I watch Karen. She occasionally looks at him. I watch John. He eats a piece of toast Pandora gave him and somehow manages to contribute nothing useful whatsoever. Eventually I ask Karen whether this concerns Mr Whiskers specifically or something near Mr Whiskers. She laughs and tells me I’m taking this too seriously, which is easy for her to say because she’s the one withholding information. I start reviewing Mr Whiskers’ recent behavior instead. Yesterday he spent an unusual amount of time at the window, and the day before that he refused to cuddle with me until we discovered he hated the smell of my new body wash. That incident demonstrated two important things: first, Mr Whiskers responds strongly to environmental changes; second, I’m capable of recognizing unusual behavior even if my initial explanation occasionally requires minor adjustment.

Maybe Karen has noticed another environmental change. A smell, perhaps, or something beneath the floor. Cats can hear frequencies humans can’t hear, so perhaps there’s a vibration coming through the building and Karen noticed Mr Whiskers reacting to it before I did. I mention the vibration possibility, and Pandora closes her eyes. Karen asks, “What vibration?” and I tell her that’s exactly what I’m trying to determine. “No, Hal. What vibration?” she asks again. I admit I don’t know yet. John begins laughing into his coffee, so I remind him that unexplained low-frequency vibrations are a real phenomenon. He agrees, which briefly encourages me until he adds that refrigerators are also a real phenomenon. I listen carefully. The refrigerator is humming, but that’s not it. I’ve heard the refrigerator before. This feels different, although admittedly I’m not actually feeling or hearing anything. Mr Whiskers might be, and that’s the important distinction. Pandora asks how I’ve gone from Karen looking at the cat to vibrations beneath the building in less than ten minutes. I tell her I’m eliminating possibilities. She asks how many possibilities I’ve eliminated. I decide to concentrate on breakfast.

Then Mr Whiskers moves. He slowly extends one paw toward the chair leg, taps something, and withdraws his paw. Karen immediately leans forward and says, “There!” I nearly knock over my coffee getting out of the chair. I ask what she saw, but she’s already pointing underneath the table. I look exactly where she’s pointing and see absolutely nothing except tile. “He touched it,” she says. I ask what he touched. Karen crouches, so I crouch beside her while John remains seated because apparently curiosity has limits. She points toward the floor behind the chair. I look again. Nothing. I tell her there’s nothing there. “Yes, there is.” I ask where. “Right there.” This goes on long enough for me to begin wondering whether Karen has developed some kind of visual ability unavailable to the rest of us. Pandora finally comes around the table, looks down, and says, “Oh.” I turn toward her immediately because I don’t appreciate the implications of that particular oh. She points. I still don’t see anything. Karen reaches underneath the chair and picks something up between two fingers. It’s tiny, smaller than a grain of rice, and when she holds it in front of me I realize it’s moving. There is a very small insect crawling across her fingertip.

I look at Karen, then at the spot where she’d been standing, then back at the insect. Apparently Karen possesses the visual acuity of a reconnaissance satellite. She carries it outside while I remain in the kitchen reconsidering several assumptions about human vision, and when she comes back I ask how she possibly saw something that small from across the room. Karen explains that she didn’t see the insect initially. She saw Mr Whiskers tracking something with his eyes. When she followed his gaze, she eventually noticed movement on the floor. That makes considerably more sense, but it also means she noticed Mr Whiskers noticing something before I noticed either of them. “I knew you saw something,” I tell her. Karen laughs and says, “Eventually.” I explain that I knew from the beginning because her expression changed. Pandora looks at John. John looks at Pandora. I point at both of them and tell them not to say whatever they’re about to say. Neither says anything, which somehow feels worse.

Karen finishes her coffee and gets ready to leave. Before she goes, she scratches Mr Whiskers behind the ears and tells him he’s a good hunter, praise he accepts despite having done absolutely nothing beyond staring at an insect until a human removed it for him. That’s cats for you. Karen says goodbye, Pandora walks her to the door, and within a few minutes the kitchen returns to normal. I sit down and finish my breakfast feeling reasonably satisfied with the outcome. Karen really did see something I didn’t. Technically, she saw Mr Whiskers seeing something neither of us initially saw, which means the information chain went from insect to cat to Karen to me. That’s a surprisingly efficient neighborhood intelligence network when you think about it, although I decide not to phrase it that way around Pandora. John finishes his coffee and asks whether I’m satisfied now. I tell him I am. There was an observable anomaly, Karen identified it, we investigated it, and the explanation turned out to be completely ordinary. No conspiracy, no coded messages, no hidden operation, just a tiny insect and a cat with better eyesight than everyone else in the room.

Mr Whiskers returns to his usual breakfast patrol as though nothing happened. He circles my chair, checks beneath the table, then sits near the doorway and begins washing one paw. I feel strangely reassured because this is how rational people handle uncertainty: they observe something unusual, gather evidence, identify the explanation, and move on. I’m getting better at this. At least that’s what I’m thinking when I notice John looking at the floor. Not casually, either. Intently. I stop eating and ask what he’s looking at, but he doesn’t answer immediately. Instead he leans slightly to one side, looks at me, and then looks at Pandora. Pandora follows his gaze toward the floor, and her expression changes. I turn around. There’s nothing there. I ask why everybody is looking at the floor. John starts laughing. Pandora tries not to. Mr Whiskers simply walks away, which seems unnecessarily judgmental.

I get out of my chair and look down again, and this time I finally see it. There’s a piece of egg stuck to my sock. Apparently it has been there long enough for everyone in the kitchen except me to notice. John is laughing hard enough now that he has to put his coffee down, while Pandora points out that this is probably what Mr Whiskers was looking at when he came over to my chair earlier. I remove the egg and throw it away. “Fine,” I say. Pandora asks whether the case is closed. I tell her it is and sit back down. There is absolutely nothing mysterious happening in this kitchen. Karen noticed an insect, Mr Whiskers noticed the insect, John noticed the egg, Pandora noticed the egg, and apparently everyone in my immediate social circle sees things I don’t. I take another bite of breakfast and begin considering whether that, by itself, represents some kind of pattern.

Pandora points her fork at me and says, “No.”

I haven’t said anything.

That’s becoming a problem.

Related Posts

• I Knew Something Was Off the Way Pandora Was Eating Cereal
• I’m Starting to Think Mr Whiskers Is Involved Somehow
• I Think She’s Leaving Clues for Mrs Jenkins

I’m sitting at the kitchen table eating cereal when I realize Mr. Whiskers hasn’t climbed into my lap. This may not sound significant to somebody unfamiliar with our morning routine, but Mr. Whiskers operates according to a remarkably dependable schedule. I sit down, he appears. I eat breakfast, he occupies my lap. I attempt to stand before he’s finished, and he somehow increases his body weight by approximately forty percent through a biological mechanism science has yet to explain. Today, however, he’s sitting several feet away near the doorway, staring at me. I pat my leg and call his name, but all I get is a slight movement of his ears, confirming that he has both heard me and deliberately chosen not to respond. That’s different. Pandora is making tea at the counter, so I ask whether Mr. Whiskers seems strange to her. She glances at him, says he looks fine, and goes back to making her tea. I explain that he isn’t sitting with me. “Maybe he doesn’t want to,” she says. Technically that’s possible, but it would represent a fairly significant change in policy. Mr. Whiskers and I have an understanding. He provides warmth and companionship; I provide food, shelter, furniture to destroy, and approximately seventeen opportunities per day for him to walk through doors he immediately wants reopened. It’s been a stable arrangement.

I get out of my chair and approach him, expecting the usual little chirp he makes when he thinks I’m about to scratch his head. Instead, Mr. Whiskers watches me coming, stands up, and walks into the living room. I stop halfway across the kitchen and look at Pandora. “Did you see that?” She takes a sip of tea and says yes. “He avoided me.” Pandora points out that he merely walked into another room, but I know what I saw. I follow him into the living room and find him sitting beside the couch. When I sit down and pat the cushion beside me, he looks at the cushion, looks at me, and remains exactly where he is. Usually I don’t even need to invite him; merely sitting somewhere expensive is enough to summon him automatically. I tell Pandora something is wrong. She tells me nothing is wrong. This is exactly the sort of reasonable explanation that makes investigating anything around Pandora unnecessarily difficult.

I’m not suggesting Mr. Whiskers is attempting to warn us about an imminent threat, but cats are observant animals, and this particular cat spends most of his life watching the rest of us make questionable decisions. Maybe something changed overnight. A sound, a smell, a person outside, something in the apartment. Animals supposedly detect earthquakes before humans do. I’ve read that somewhere, although I can’t remember where and I’m not entirely sure it’s true. Before I can investigate further, I hear faint footsteps outside the apartment followed by a scraping sound near the door. Mr. Whiskers’ ears immediately point forward, which is exactly the sort of reaction I was talking about. I quietly approach the door while Pandora asks what I’m doing. I put one finger to my lips, which she doesn’t appreciate, and look through the peephole. Mrs. Jenkins is outside carrying a small bag in one hand and maneuvering a planter with the other. I open the door, she says hello, and I discover that the suspicious scraping noise was nothing more than the planter shifting against the floor while she adjusted her grip. She asks if everything is okay. I tell her everything is fine, and after a slightly confusing moment in which both of us appear to be waiting for the other person to explain why we’re having this conversation, she continues on her way.

Fine. The footsteps were Mrs. Jenkins. That’s one mystery solved, except Mr. Whiskers still won’t come near me. A little later John Mercer stops by, and within seconds the cat walks directly over to greet him. Now we have a control group. I watch Mr. Whiskers rub against John’s leg while John scratches him behind the ears, and I can’t help feeling personally betrayed. “You’ve got to be kidding me,” I say. John looks up and asks what’s wrong, so I explain that Mr. Whiskers has been avoiding me all morning. John looks down at the orange cat currently leaning into his hand and says he seems fine. “Exactly,” I tell him. John doesn’t understand why that’s important, although Pandora does because I can hear her laughing from the kitchen. The cat isn’t withdrawn, frightened, or uninterested in people. He’s avoiding one specific person, and unfortunately that person is me.

I ask John whether anything unusual happened recently involving Mr. Whiskers. John says no. I ask whether he’s given him anything unusual to eat, brought anything strange into the apartment, or changed any scented products recently. John stops petting the cat and asks why his deodorant has suddenly become relevant. Pandora tells me to stop interviewing him, and I explain that an interview would be structured; this is preliminary information gathering. John sits down on the couch, and Mr. Whiskers jumps up beside him within thirty seconds, which does nothing to improve the situation. I begin reviewing the previous twenty-four hours in my head. Nothing unusual happened last night. Pandora and I watched television, Mr. Whiskers spent part of the evening on the couch, and everything seemed normal when we went to bed. This morning I got up, showered, got dressed, poured myself some cereal, and discovered I’d been socially exiled by a twelve-pound orange mammal. Somewhere in that sequence, something changed.

John suggests that maybe Mr. Whiskers is simply being a cat, which is the sort of thing people say whenever they don’t understand cats. I get up and approach him again. This time I watch carefully. Mr. Whiskers doesn’t immediately move. He watches me coming, and when I’m about three feet away his nose twitches. Then he gets up and walks to the other end of the couch. I freeze. His nose twitched. That’s new evidence. I smell my shirt, then my sleeve, while John asks what on earth I’m doing. Nothing seems unusual, but then I remember that after my shower this morning I used the new body wash Pandora bought. I turn toward her. She immediately knows what I’m thinking. “The body wash,” I say. Pandora’s expression changes just enough for me to notice. I accuse her of knowing, and she says she didn’t know anything; she merely wondered whether the new scent might bother him. That’s close enough to prior knowledge that I feel she could have mentioned it earlier.

I retrieve the bottle from the bathroom and bring it back into the living room. Pandora immediately warns me not to put body wash anywhere near the cat, which I wasn’t planning to do because I’m conducting an investigation, not poisoning a witness. From several feet away I open the cap. Mr. Whiskers’ reaction is immediate. His ears turn sideways, his eyes narrow, and he jumps off the couch before leaving the room with an urgency he hasn’t demonstrated all morning. John starts laughing. Pandora tries not to, fails, and joins him. I stare down at the bottle and read the label. Apparently the fragrance contains cedar, citrus, and “smoked amber,” which sounds less like something designed for human hygiene and more like the description of a forest shortly after an evacuation order. “This is why he won’t cuddle with me,” I say. Pandora points out that I simply smell different. I tell her I smell offensive. “To the cat,” she says, as though that distinction somehow improves things.

Everything suddenly makes sense. Mr. Whiskers wasn’t sensing danger, reacting to Mrs. Jenkins, detecting something hidden in the apartment, or attempting to warn me about an unseen threat. He just thinks I stink. John helpfully points out that I was technically correct when I said the cat had noticed something before I did, and I appreciate his willingness to acknowledge that. Pandora doesn’t seem nearly as impressed. I go shower again using my old soap, and when I return Mr. Whiskers is sitting on the windowsill. I don’t approach him this time. I sit on the couch and wait because trust has clearly been damaged and rebuilding relationships takes patience. After about thirty seconds he jumps down, walks toward me, and sniffs my leg. I remain perfectly still. He jumps onto the couch, climbs into my lap, turns around twice, and settles down as though the entire morning never happened. I look at Pandora with what I consider a justified expression of triumph. She smiles and says, “You smelled like a candle.” I tell her that’s still something.

With Mr. Whiskers purring in my lap again, I decide I’ve learned something valuable. Not every unusual behavior is evidence of a conspiracy. Sometimes the simplest explanation really is the correct one. Mrs. Jenkins wasn’t involved. John wasn’t involved. Pandora wasn’t hiding anything. The neighborhood wasn’t communicating through cats. I changed one small variable in my morning routine, Mr. Whiskers objected to smelling like he’d been trapped inside a cedar chest during a wildfire, and everything returned to normal when I corrected the problem. It’s perfectly logical, and I’m actually proud of myself for accepting the explanation without trying to connect it to anything larger. That’s progress, especially considering some of the conclusions I’ve reached lately.

Then Mr. Whiskers suddenly lifts his head. His purring stops, his ears point toward the window, and a second later he jumps off my lap and races to the windowsill. I follow his gaze and see Mrs. Jenkins standing near her plants while Karen talks to her. Neither woman appears to be doing anything particularly unusual. Then Mrs. Jenkins looks toward our window. Mr. Whiskers meows. I lean forward. Pandora sees me and immediately says, “No.” I remind her that I haven’t said anything. She tells me I don’t have to. Mr. Whiskers meows again, looks toward Mrs. Jenkins, and then turns his head toward me. I look at him. He looks at me. I’m not saying that’s communication. We’ve just established the dangers of jumping to conclusions, and I’m taking that lesson seriously. I’m merely pointing out that Mr. Whiskers is cuddling with me again, which means whatever he’s concerned about now clearly has nothing to do with the body wash.

That’s a completely separate matter.

Related Posts

• I’m Starting to Think Mr Whiskers Is Involved Somehow
• I’m Starting to Suspect Mr Whiskers Knows More
• I Just Realized Mr Whiskers Has Been Watching John Very Closely

I’m sitting on the couch watching Mr. Whiskers methodically lick one paw while Pandora makes dinner in the kitchen, and for perhaps three consecutive minutes everything in my life seems completely normal. Something smells incredible from the kitchen, Mr. Whiskers appears satisfied with whatever progress he’s making on his left foot, and I’m considering whether getting up to investigate dinner would constitute helping or merely interfering. Then I notice the gardening gloves on the coffee table.

They’re green, slightly muddy, and unmistakably Mrs. Jenkins’. I’ve seen them enough times to recognize them because Mrs. Jenkins wears them whenever she’s working around her plants. I don’t know why I’ve retained this information, but apparently somewhere in my brain there’s now a department responsible for identifying neighborhood gardening equipment. I stare at the gloves for several seconds before calling toward the kitchen, “Pandora?” She answers without coming into the room. I ask why Mrs. Jenkins’ gardening gloves are on our coffee table. There’s a pause, followed by, “I don’t know.” I look at the gloves again. That’s not the answer I wanted.

Pandora comes into the living room carrying a wooden spoon and looks at the coffee table. She seems considerably less impressed by the situation than I am. “Maybe she left them here,” she says. I ask when Mrs. Jenkins would have been here to leave gardening gloves on our coffee table. Pandora shrugs and says she doesn’t know, which means we’re now two questions into this situation without producing a single useful answer. She returns to the kitchen. Mr. Whiskers continues cleaning himself. Nobody seems remotely concerned that another person’s belongings have materialized inside our home.

I lean forward and inspect the gloves without touching them. There’s dried soil along the fingers and something pale stuck near one cuff that might be a leaf. They look used recently. That’s important, although I haven’t yet determined why. Mrs. Jenkins usually keeps her gardening things with the rest of her supplies, so the gloves being here means that at some point they traveled from wherever Mrs. Jenkins keeps them to our living room. Objects don’t generally relocate themselves. Somebody brought them here. That’s not paranoia. That’s physics.

Mr. Whiskers stops licking his paw and looks at the gloves. Finally, somebody else has noticed. He leans forward, sniffs one of them, and immediately loses interest. I find this disappointing because if there’s anyone in the apartment qualified to identify unusual outdoor smells, it’s him. “Nothing?” I ask. Mr. Whiskers turns around twice and settles into a different position. Pandora calls from the kitchen and asks if I’m questioning the cat again. I tell her I’m not questioning him; I’m observing his reaction. She says that’s worse. I don’t see how.

A few minutes later, I hear footsteps outside and glance through the window. John Mercer is walking toward the building while looking at his phone. He looks preoccupied, which is not particularly unusual for John, but because I’m currently sitting beside unexplained gardening gloves, his expression acquires context it probably doesn’t deserve. He comes up a few minutes later, and when Pandora lets him in, I decide not to mention the gloves immediately. Instead, I watch him enter the living room. His eyes pass over the coffee table, move toward me, then return to the gloves for just a fraction of a second.

There.

Recognition.

John sits down. I wait.

He checks his phone.

I wait longer.

Finally I ask, “Anything you want to tell me?” John looks up and asks what I’m talking about. I glance toward the coffee table. He follows my eyes and sees the gloves. “Oh,” he says. That’s not a denial. I ask whether he recognizes them. He says they’re gardening gloves. I explain that I’m aware of their general classification and ask whether he recognizes these particular gardening gloves. John looks at me for several seconds before asking why he would recognize Mrs. Jenkins’ gloves. I point at him. “You knew they were hers.” John reminds me that I just asked whether he recognized Mrs. Jenkins’ gardening gloves. That’s unfortunate. I may have contaminated the interview.

Pandora returns from the kitchen and asks John whether he’s staying for dinner. He says he doesn’t want to impose. She tells him there’s plenty. I watch this exchange carefully because normal conversation can sometimes conceal extraordinary amounts of information. John agrees to stay. Pandora goes back to the kitchen. Nothing suspicious happens. Somehow that feels suspicious too. I look at the gloves again and start considering the possibilities. Maybe Mrs. Jenkins stopped by earlier. Maybe Pandora borrowed them. Maybe John brought them over for some reason. Maybe Mr. Whiskers dragged them inside, although the logistics of a cat transporting two gardening gloves through a closed front door would require additional investigation.

I ask John whether he’s spoken to Mrs. Jenkins today. He says no. Yesterday? No. Recently? He thinks for a moment and says he waved to her a few days ago. I ask whether she was gardening. John looks increasingly concerned about where this conversation is heading. “Probably,” he says. Probably isn’t useful. I ask whether she was wearing gloves. He tells me he has absolutely no idea. That’s either genuine ignorance or extremely disciplined operational security.

Pandora tells me from the kitchen to leave John alone. I point out that I’ve asked him four questions. She says that’s four more questions than a normal person would ask about gardening gloves. John nods. I catch him doing it. “See, that,” I say. “That right there.” He asks what he did. “You and Pandora just agreed without discussing it first.” John stares at me. Pandora stops stirring whatever she’s cooking long enough to look into the living room. “Hal,” she says. I decide this might be a good moment to reduce the intensity of the investigation.

The problem is that once I start thinking about the gloves, I start noticing the neighborhood itself. Mrs. Jenkins spends a lot of time around her plants. Karen seems to know everything happening within approximately fifty yards of her front door. John appears at unpredictable times. Mr. Whiskers spends hours watching all of them through the window. None of those things means anything individually, but neighborhoods are essentially collections of people living close enough together to observe one another while pretending they aren’t observing one another. When you think about it that way, the entire concept is suspicious.

I go to the window. Mrs. Jenkins is outside near her plants. She’s carrying a watering can, but she’s not wearing gloves. Obviously she isn’t wearing gloves because her gloves are approximately six feet behind me on the coffee table. The significance of this is enormous until I remember that I’ve already established where the gloves are. I watch her move between the pots, occasionally stopping to examine something. Perfectly normal gardening behavior. Then Karen appears and says something to her. Mrs. Jenkins laughs. Karen looks toward our building. I instinctively move slightly away from the window.

John notices. “Did you just hide?”

“No.”

“You moved away from the window.”

“I repositioned.”

“Why?”

I don’t answer because I’m not entirely sure.

Pandora comes out of the kitchen, follows my line of sight, and sees Karen talking to Mrs. Jenkins. “What now?” she asks. I tell her nothing is happening. She says that’s reassuring. I explain that I’m merely beginning to appreciate how much information passes through a neighborhood every day. People see things. People talk. Mrs. Jenkins knows Karen. Karen knows us. John knows everybody. Mr. Whiskers watches the street. Pandora listens to this explanation with increasing concern before asking whether I’ve somehow turned gardening gloves into a surveillance network.

When she says it like that, it sounds ridiculous.

I return to the couch.

“Fine. Simple explanation. Mrs. Jenkins left her gloves here.”

Pandora nods.

“Except neither of us remembers her being here.”

Pandora stops nodding.

John looks at the gloves.

For the first time all evening, I feel like I have everyone’s attention.

“Exactly.”

Pandora thinks for a moment, then suddenly says, “Wait.” She walks toward the front door, opens it, and looks outside. A second later she calls Mrs. Jenkins’ name. I hear Mrs. Jenkins answer from somewhere below. Pandora asks whether she’s missing a pair of gardening gloves. There’s a pause.

Then Mrs. Jenkins starts laughing.

I don’t appreciate that.

A minute later she comes up and explains everything. Earlier that afternoon she’d been carrying groceries along with some gardening supplies when Pandora encountered her near the entrance. Pandora helped carry a couple of bags upstairs while Mrs. Jenkins dealt with the rest. The gloves had apparently been tucked into the top of one of the bags and fallen onto our entryway floor. Pandora found them later, put them on the coffee table intending to return them, then became distracted making dinner and forgot.

That’s it.

No secret meetings. No coded gardening operation. No neighborhood surveillance network. A pair of gloves fell out of a grocery bag.

Pandora looks at me.

John looks at me.

Mrs. Jenkins looks at me.

Even Mr. Whiskers looks at me, although he’s probably responding to the additional person in the room.

I pick up the gloves and hand them to Mrs. Jenkins. “Mystery solved.”

She takes them and asks what mystery.

“No mystery.”

Pandora makes a noise from the kitchen that sounds suspiciously like a laugh.

Mrs. Jenkins thanks us and heads back outside. John returns to his phone. Pandora returns to dinner. Mr. Whiskers resumes washing himself. Within thirty seconds the entire apartment has returned to normal, and I feel slightly foolish for having constructed an intelligence network around a pair of muddy gloves.

Still, my fundamental observation was correct. The gloves were somewhere they didn’t belong. There was an explanation. I found the explanation. That’s essentially what investigation is.

I decide not to mention that to Pandora.

Dinner is almost ready when I look through the window again. Mrs. Jenkins is back near her plants wearing the gloves. Karen is gone. Everything looks ordinary. I feel an unexpected sense of relief. Maybe I’ve been looking for patterns where there aren’t any. Maybe a neighborhood is just a neighborhood. People borrow things, lose things, talk to each other, carry groceries, tend gardens, and occasionally leave gardening equipment in somebody else’s home. Not everything has to connect.

Then Mrs. Jenkins stops beside one of the large planters.

She looks left.

She looks right.

Then she reaches behind it and pulls out a small metal box.

I stop chewing.

John notices my expression. “No.”

I point toward the window.

“No,” he says again.

“You haven’t even looked.”

“I don’t need to.”

Pandora turns around. “What?”

I don’t answer. I’m watching Mrs. Jenkins.

She opens the box, puts something inside, closes it, and slides it behind the planter again.

The room goes quiet.

At least I think it does. It might just be me.

Pandora walks over and looks through the window. “Probably gardening stuff.”

“Then why is it in a metal box?”

“Because she wants it in a metal box.”

“Behind a planter?”

Pandora gives me the look.

I know the look.

I’ve seen the look.

The look means I’m supposed to accept the reasonable explanation and continue eating dinner like a functioning adult.

So I do.

I sit back down. I take another bite. I don’t mention the box. I don’t ask John what he thinks. I don’t interrogate Mr. Whiskers. I don’t go downstairs. I don’t even look through the window again.

For almost two full minutes.

That’s when Karen comes back.

She walks directly toward Mrs. Jenkins’ garden.

I slowly put down my fork.

Pandora sees me.

“Hal.”

“I’m eating.”

“You stopped eating.”

“I’m chewing.”

“You’re not chewing.”

I start chewing.

John refuses to turn around.

Mr. Whiskers jumps onto the windowsill.

I point at him.

“That’s not me.”

Pandora closes her eyes.

Outside, Karen bends toward the planter.

I’m not saying there’s a neighborhood conspiracy.

That would be irresponsible.

I’m saying the gardening gloves have been fully explained, and therefore they’re no longer relevant to the investigation.

The metal box, however, is new evidence.

Related Posts

• The Cat’s Behavior Is More Suspicious Than I Thought
• I’m Starting to Suspect Mr Whiskers Knows More
• The Cookies on the Coffee Table Are Watching Me

I walk into the kitchen and immediately know something has happened. The sugar jar has moved. Normally it sits beside the toaster, slightly behind the coffee container and far enough from the edge that Mr. Whiskers can’t reach it without committing to an operation. Today it’s sitting on the opposite side of the counter near the refrigerator. I stop in the doorway and look at Pandora, who’s standing at the sink. “Did you move the sugar?” She turns around and asks what I’m talking about, so I point at the jar. She looks at it, looks back at me, and casually says yes before returning to whatever she’s doing in the sink. That’s interesting. Normally when somebody admits to moving something, there’s an explanation attached to it. *I was cleaning. I needed it. It was in the way. The cat was attempting a burglary.* Something. Pandora has given me nothing.

I ask why she moved it, and without turning around she says she needed it. Naturally, I ask what she needed it for. “Something,” she says. There it is. Something. I don’t like indefinite pronouns before coffee. I walk over to the counter and examine the jar. The lid is on correctly, nothing appears damaged, and the amount of sugar inside looks slightly lower than I remember, although I recognize that estimating granular volume by sight is probably not considered reliable evidence in most jurisdictions. Pandora dries her hands and asks if I’m okay. I tell her I’m fine. She points out that I’m staring at the sugar, and I explain that I’m merely looking at it, which she insists is exactly what staring means. Before I can defend the distinction, Mr. Whiskers walks into the kitchen and immediately goes to Pandora. She bends down and scratches his head, and he starts purring. I make a mental note. Pandora looks directly at me and says, “Don’t.” I haven’t actually done anything, but apparently I’ve developed a recognizable face for this sort of thing.

Pandora leaves the kitchen, and Mr. Whiskers follows her, leaving me alone with the sugar. There are moments in a person’s life when instinct tells him something important has changed. Sometimes it’s a tone of voice. Sometimes it’s an unfamiliar car outside. Sometimes it’s a mysterious phone call. Sometimes it’s three inches of countertop. I pour myself some coffee and review what I know. Pandora moved the sugar. Pandora needed the sugar for “something.” Pandora declined to identify what that something was. Then Pandora left the room with Mr. Whiskers immediately following her. That’s three facts, possibly four if the purring matters. I’m not saying it does. I’m merely saying we shouldn’t exclude anything prematurely.

John Mercer stops by a little later, and I wait until he’s comfortably settled before asking whether Pandora has mentioned sugar recently. He stares at me for several seconds before saying no. I tell him to think about it. He says he doesn’t need to. I suggest she might have mentioned baking, coffee, dessert, or anything involving granulated sweeteners, at which point John looks past me toward Pandora, who’s sitting at the table working on her laptop. Without even looking up, she says, “Don’t help him.” John nods immediately. I point at him and ask what that was. He asks what I mean. “The nod,” I say. John explains that Pandora told him not to help me, so he agreed not to help me. Technically that makes sense, but I’m still uncomfortable with how quickly the two of them established cooperation.

I sit down across from Pandora and remind myself that I’m not going to interrogate her. This is my wife. If Pandora says she needed sugar for something, then she needed sugar for something. That’s a perfectly reasonable explanation between two adults who trust each other. I drink my coffee and manage approximately thirty seconds of mature silence before asking what she’s working on. She stops typing and says, “Work.” I ask what kind of work. “My work.” I hesitate before asking whether it’s related to sugar. Pandora slowly looks up from the laptop while John, from somewhere behind me, makes the exhausted sound of a man reconsidering his decision to visit. Pandora says no. That’s good. We’ve eliminated one possibility.

The problem is that once you know somebody is withholding one small piece of information, you begin noticing everything else. Over the next hour Pandora checks her phone twice, goes into the bedroom and closes the door for approximately six minutes, returns carrying nothing, and later opens a kitchen cabinet, looks inside, and closes it again. None of these things are suspicious individually. Taken together, they are also not suspicious, and I’m trying very hard to remember that. Mr. Whiskers isn’t helping. Every time Pandora gets up, he seems to know where she’s going before I do. She heads toward the kitchen and he follows. She walks toward the bedroom and he watches from the hallway. It’s almost as though he’s tracking her movements, although admittedly it’s equally possible that he’s a cat who has correctly identified Pandora as a reliable source of food.

Eventually John leaves, but before going he tells me not to turn “the sugar thing” into another situation. I ask what he means by *another* situation, but he leaves without answering, thereby creating a second mystery while advising me not to investigate the first. I decide not to pursue it. That’s growth. By late afternoon I’ve almost forgotten about the sugar when someone knocks at the door. It’s Karen. Pandora gets there before I do, and the two of them talk quietly in the hallway. I’m in the living room, far enough away that I can’t hear everything they’re saying, which is fine because intentionally listening would be eavesdropping. I can, however, hear Karen say something containing the word “tonight.” Pandora laughs, Karen says something else, and then Pandora says very clearly, “He doesn’t know.”

I freeze. Mr. Whiskers is sitting beside me, and even his ears rotate toward the hallway. I look at him. He looks at me. Now we’re dealing with evidence. When Pandora comes back inside, I ask what I don’t know. She stops, and Karen, still standing outside, makes the catastrophic mistake of smiling. Pandora looks at Karen, Karen’s smile disappears, and Pandora asks what I’m talking about. I tell her I heard her say, “He doesn’t know.” She claims she said, “You don’t know.” I point out that this is actually worse. Pandora sighs, closes the door, and walks past me. Suddenly the sugar isn’t random anymore. The phone isn’t random. The closed bedroom door isn’t random. Karen isn’t random. Something is happening.

I remain calm and ask what I don’t know. Pandora says, “Nothing,” which is unfortunate because nobody in recorded history has ever successfully used the word *nothing* in that particular situation. I stare at her until she finally says, “You’re going to ruin it.” That changes everything. I ask what I’m going to ruin, but she refuses to answer. I ask whether it involves John. No. Karen? No. Mrs. Jenkins? No. Dave? Pandora looks genuinely confused and asks why Dave would possibly be involved. That’s an excellent question, actually, so I remove Dave from the investigation. Finally I ask whether Mr. Whiskers is involved. Pandora laughs so hard that even the cat looks offended.

For the rest of the afternoon I attempt to behave normally, which turns out to be extremely difficult once you’ve confirmed the existence of an undisclosed event. Every sound acquires meaning. Every cabinet opening has context. Every time Pandora checks her phone, information is potentially being exchanged. Then she walks into the kitchen carrying a grocery bag and tells me not to come in. That’s when I know beyond reasonable doubt that an operation is underway. I stand outside the kitchen and ask what she’s doing. She says nothing. I point out that I can hear noises. She tells me kitchens have noises. A few seconds later I hear what sounds unmistakably like a mixer. Pandora insists I didn’t hear a mixer. Then I smell vanilla, and the entire conspiracy begins collapsing under the weight of its own deliciousness.

I ask if she’s baking something. There’s a long silence, followed by the kitchen door opening. Pandora stands there with flour on her shirt and the expression of somebody whose surprise has just been destroyed by a man incapable of ignoring displaced condiments. Behind her, sitting on the counter, is a partially frosted cake. I look at the cake, then at Pandora, and suddenly remember that tomorrow is the anniversary of the day we first met. The revelation arrives all at once, along with the uncomfortable realization that I absolutely should have remembered this sooner.

Pandora explains that Karen was helping her plan a surprise. The sugar moved because Pandora had measured ingredients earlier and forgot to put the jar back. She’d been checking her phone because Karen was helping with the recipe. She’d closed the bedroom door because she’d hidden a gift in there. When she told Karen that I didn’t know, she meant exactly what it sounded like: I wasn’t supposed to know because it was a surprise. Every clue I’d noticed was real. Every observation had been accurate. My conclusion had merely been catastrophically wrong.

I look at the cake and then back at Pandora. “So you *were* keeping secrets from me.” She stares at me for a moment before admitting that, technically, yes, she was. I don’t have enough time to enjoy this victory before she picks up a dish towel and throws it at my head. I catch it, which I consider an impressive display of reflexes under hostile conditions. Mr. Whiskers wanders into the kitchen and immediately sits beside Pandora. Of course he does. I point at him and tell Pandora he clearly knew what was happening. She warns me not to interrogate the cat. I assure her I’m not interrogating anybody, then crouch beside Mr. Whiskers and quietly ask how long he’s known. Pandora orders me out of the kitchen.

I retreat to the couch smiling because, technically, I was right about the most important thing. Pandora was keeping a secret. It happened to be a good secret involving cake rather than whatever sprawling domestic conspiracy my brain had begun constructing, but I’m willing to accept that as a favorable outcome. I decide the investigation is officially closed and settle back into the couch feeling unusually pleased with my restraint. A few minutes later, Mr. Whiskers walks past carrying a small piece of blue ribbon in his mouth. I watch him disappear down the hallway and remember that Pandora said she’d hidden *a* gift in the bedroom. Singular. The ribbon is blue. The shopping bag she carried into the bedroom earlier was red.

I stare at the hallway for several seconds before reminding myself that I’ve learned my lesson. There is no reason to investigate. Pandora has already explained everything. The sugar mystery is solved, the conspiracy doesn’t exist, and whatever Mr. Whiskers is doing with that ribbon is almost certainly none of my business. I lean back against the couch and force myself to relax. Five seconds pass. Then ten. Somewhere down the hallway, Mr. Whiskers knocks something over.

I get up.

I’m only going to look.

Related Posts

• I Think John Mercer is Hiding Something in My Kitchen
• I’m Certain Pandora’s Coffee Came from Elsewhere
• I Knew It Wasn’t My Imagination About That Mug

I’m walking back to the flat with Pandora’s hand in mine when I notice something off about John Mercer’s car. It’s parked outside our place where I’ve seen it a hundred times before, except today something about it catches my attention. The wheels look more scuffed than they did last week, and there’s a small dent in the passenger-side door that I’m almost certain wasn’t there before. Now, this could mean absolutely nothing. John has never struck me as a man who considers painted lines in a parking lot to be legally binding, so a few scratches and a dent aren’t exactly shocking developments. Still, I slow down, and Pandora keeps walking for another half step before realizing I’ve stopped. When she looks back at me, I’m staring at John’s car like it has just failed a background check. “What?” she asks. “Nothing,” I say, which is what people say when something is definitely becoming something. Pandora gives my hand a little squeeze and starts toward the building again, but now I’m looking at the car more carefully. There’s dirt along the lower panels, a scrape near one wheel, and that dent. John has apparently been putting some miles on this thing. Of course, cars are specifically designed for putting miles on them, so this observation should not be particularly alarming. Unfortunately, my brain has already convened a committee.

I glance toward our window and spot Mr Whiskers sitting on the sill, staring down at us with his tail flicking behind him. Even from here, he looks judgmental, which I choose to interpret as support for my investigation. I’ve been trying to shake this feeling about John for a while now, but little things keep sticking with me. His early Tuesday mornings, for example. Maybe he goes to the gym. Maybe he gets breakfast. Maybe he has an appointment. There are hundreds of perfectly reasonable explanations for a grown man leaving home early on a Tuesday, and somehow my brain has rejected all of them in favor of clandestine activity. The dent isn’t helping. Was it a parking accident? Did somebody hit him? Did he hit somebody else? Has John been driving around late at night? Why do I even care? Pandora squeezes my hand again, which makes me care more. I look at her, she looks at me, and when she asks, “What?” for the second time, I tell her she keeps squeezing my hand. “I’m holding your hand, Hal,” she says. Fair point.

We start walking again, but I glance over my shoulder at John’s car and remember what Karen mentioned recently about seeing somebody she didn’t recognize walking around the neighborhood late at night. When I asked what the person looked like, she shrugged and admitted she hadn’t gotten a good look. At the time, I dismissed it because people walk around neighborhoods and that is generally how neighborhoods work, but now there’s John’s car, the dent, and those Tuesday mornings. I immediately recognize that I am constructing a criminal conspiracy out of automotive wear and a weekday, which should probably be enough to stop me. It isn’t. Mrs Jenkins’ voice floats through my memory instead: “You can’t be too careful these days.” That woman could say the same thing about expired yogurt and somehow make it sound like a warning from the intelligence services. Maybe Karen really did see somebody suspicious. Maybe John really has been driving somewhere unusually early. Maybe the dent really is new. Those three things could theoretically be connected, although they could just as easily have absolutely nothing to do with one another.

Pandora pulls me gently toward the entrance and asks if we’re going inside. “In a minute,” I tell her, still looking at the car. She follows my gaze and immediately says, “Oh no.” I ask what she means, and she tells me I’m doing the thing again. I insist that I don’t have a thing, which earns me the sort of look that confirms I absolutely have a thing. “Have you noticed that dent before?” I ask. Pandora studies it for approximately two seconds before saying no, and my eyebrows go up before she can add, “That doesn’t mean it wasn’t there.” Interesting. Very interesting. Not actually interesting, obviously, but my brain has already written it down. I crouch slightly to get a better look at the passenger side while Pandora stands behind me with the patient expression of a woman who has apparently accepted that this is how her evening is going now. Maybe John clipped a shopping cart. Maybe somebody opened a door into him. Maybe he backed into something. Those are the reasonable explanations, which means my brain immediately offers another possibility: maybe somebody was trying to get into the car.

I stand up quickly enough that Pandora notices. She asks what I’m thinking now, and I tell her it’s nothing. “Hal,” she says, in that particular tone that means she knows perfectly well it isn’t nothing. “Karen saw somebody.” Pandora reminds me that Karen saw somebody walking. I point out that it was at night. She reminds me that people also walk at night. I point out that it was near here. “We live near here,” she says, which is another annoyingly strong argument. I look toward our window again, hoping for some moral support from Mr Whiskers, but he’s washing one paw now and appears to have lost confidence in the investigation. The trouble is, the harder I try to convince myself that there’s nothing strange about John’s car, the more details I begin noticing. There’s something on the back seat that I can’t quite identify through the glass, maybe a jacket or a bag, and there’s a receipt or piece of paper wedged near the center console. They are completely ordinary things and evidence of absolutely nothing, so naturally I lean closer to the window.

Pandora catches the back of my shirt before I can get any closer and tells me not to press my face against John’s car. I tell her I wasn’t going to, and she tells me I absolutely was. I straighten up with what dignity remains and let her pull me toward the building, but another thought occurs to me before we reach the door. John has always been spontaneous. He’s the king of last-minute plans, sudden errands, and random suggestions to go somewhere. I used to think that was simply John being John, and it probably is simply John being John, but what if it isn’t? What if those spontaneous trips aren’t actually spontaneous? I stop walking again, and Pandora groans before I’ve even said anything. “What if John plans his spontaneity?” I ask. She stares at me long enough for me to realize how ridiculous that sounded. “That sentence made more sense before I said it,” I admit. “No,” Pandora says, opening the building door. “I don’t think it did.”

Before following her inside, I take one final look at John Mercer’s car. The scratched wheels, the dent, the dirt along the bottom of the doors—none of it is remarkable, and none of it is sinister. It’s just an ordinary car belonging to an ordinary man who probably bumped into something in a parking lot. That’s the sensible explanation, and I am perfectly willing to accept it. Mostly. The problem is that I can’t quite forget Karen’s stranger or John’s Tuesday mornings, and somewhere in the back of my mind those unrelated details have begun arranging themselves into a pattern. I know how this works. First there’s one thing that seems strange, then another thing that might be strange, and eventually I’m standing outside someone’s car examining a dent while my girlfriend physically prevents me from putting my face against the window. There is probably an important lesson in there somewhere, although at the moment I’m more interested in the dent.

Mr Whiskers is waiting for us when we reach the flat, sitting near the door as though he’s been expecting a full report. I bend down and scratch behind his ears while Pandora heads farther inside. “You saw it too, didn’t you?” I whisper. Mr Whiskers blinks slowly at me. “Do not involve the cat,” Pandora calls from the other room. I look at Mr Whiskers, and Mr Whiskers looks back at me. Neither of us says anything, which is hardly surprising in his case, but there’s something about the expression on his little face that makes me glance toward the window one more time. From here I can just make out the top of John Mercer’s car below. It’s probably nothing. The dent is probably nothing, the scuffed wheels are probably nothing, the Tuesday mornings are probably nothing, and Karen’s mysterious nighttime pedestrian is almost certainly nothing. I scratch Mr Whiskers under the chin and tell myself that I’m done thinking about it. Then his ears suddenly perk toward the window, and I narrow my eyes. “Exactly,” I whisper. From the other room, Pandora sighs.

Related Posts

• Pandora Left Her Phone Behind Today
• I Think Mr Whiskers Is Trying to Tell Me Something
• I’m Starting to Suspect My Roommates of Collusion

I’m sitting in the living room watching John Mercer attempt to replace a guitar string, and based on the noises he’s making, I’m beginning to suspect the guitar has insulted his family. He’s hunched over the coffee table with the guitar across his lap, muttering under his breath while Mr. Whiskers occupies approximately forty percent of the available workspace. John keeps gently moving him. Mr. Whiskers keeps moving back. At this point, I’m not sure which one of them actually owns the coffee table.

Pandora walked through about twenty minutes ago and said, “I need to study for that test today.”

That was it.

One sentence.

Perfectly ordinary.

Except she looked directly at me when she said it.

I’ve been thinking about that.

John pulls the string tight, winces, loosens it again, and mutters something I can’t quite hear.

“What test?”

John looks up. “What?”

“The test Pandora mentioned.”

“How would I know?”

“You were sitting right there.”

“So were you.”

That’s technically true, but not helpful.

I look toward the hallway where Pandora disappeared. She hasn’t mentioned any test recently. At least not that I remember. Pandora talks about work, things she’s reading, things she needs to do, and occasionally television shows I’ve apparently agreed to watch despite having no memory of agreeing to them. A test seems like something I would remember.

Unless she deliberately waited until John was here to mention it.

Interesting.

John breaks the guitar string.

Mr. Whiskers immediately raises his head.

John closes his eyes.

I decide this isn’t the right moment to share my theory.

A few minutes later, John has another string out of the package and is starting over. Mr. Whiskers has repositioned himself beside the guitar and is watching with the expression of a building inspector who has already found several violations.

“You know,” I say, “Pandora looked at me when she mentioned the test.”

John doesn’t look up. “People generally look at other people when they talk to them.”

“Not like that.”

“Like what?”

“Deliberately.”

John stops working.

He looks at me deliberately.

“Like this?”

“No.”

He goes back to the guitar.

Now I’m thinking about yesterday. Pandora was quieter than usual. She spent part of the evening looking at something on her laptop and closed it when I walked past. At the time I assumed it was work. But what if she was studying?

That would make sense.

Except why wouldn’t she tell me what the test was?

Maybe she thought I already knew.

That’s possible.

Or maybe the test isn’t hers.

I sit forward.

John notices.

“No.”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You made the face.”

Apparently I have a face now.

“What if she wasn’t studying *for* a test?”

John sighs.

“What if she was studying *me* for a test?”

John puts the guitar down.

“Hal.”

“Think about it.”

“I don’t want to.”

“She specifically said, ‘that test.’ Not ‘a test.’ *That* test. Definite article.”

“I know what ‘that’ means.”

“So there was previous knowledge.”

“Probably hers.”

“Or mine.”

“You didn’t know about it.”

“Exactly.”

John stares at me.

Mr. Whiskers stares at me.

It’s unsettling when they coordinate.

I begin reconstructing Pandora’s recent behavior. Yesterday she asked what I would do if I found twenty dollars on the sidewalk. Two days ago she asked whether I thought people could really tell when someone was lying. Last week she asked if I would rather know exactly what people thought about me or remain blissfully ignorant.

At the time, I assumed these were normal relationship questions.

Now I’m not so sure.

What if those were preliminary questions?

What if I’ve already been taking the test?

I stand up.

John immediately says, “Sit down.”

“I need coffee.”

“You’re going to investigate.”

“I can do both.”

I go into the kitchen and pour myself a cup. Mr. Whiskers follows me, which I initially interpret as support until I remember his food bowl is also in the kitchen.

Still, timing matters.

Pandora’s laptop is sitting at the end of the kitchen counter.

Closed.

I look at it.

Mr. Whiskers looks at it.

“No.”

He looks at me.

“We respect privacy.”

Mr. Whiskers licks his paw.

“Exactly.”

I take my coffee back into the living room without touching the laptop. This is growth.

John has resumed working on the guitar.

I sit down.

For approximately thirty seconds, everything is peaceful.

Then Pandora walks into the room carrying a notebook.

I try not to look interested.

She sits in the chair across from me and opens it.

I look at John.

John keeps his eyes on the guitar with an intensity that tells me he’s intentionally refusing to participate.

Pandora starts reading.

I wait.

She turns a page.

I wait longer.

Finally, I can’t take it.

“What test?”

Pandora looks up.

“The one I mentioned.”

“Yes. That one.”

She waits.

I realize she’s making me ask the entire question.

“What test are you studying for?”

“The certification test.”

I blink.

“What certification test?”

“The one for work.”

There is a pause.

John’s mouth twitches.

I don’t appreciate that.

Pandora reminds me that she told me about it two weeks ago. Apparently, we had an entire conversation about the certification, when she planned to take it, how much studying she needed to do, and why passing it would be useful.

I remember none of this.

Then she tells me where the conversation happened.

We were sitting right here.

I was watching television.

That narrows it down considerably.

She tells me what I was watching.

Now I remember.

Sort of.

There was an explosion.

Possibly a helicopter.

Pandora had been talking during it.

I suddenly understand what happened.

“You tested me.”

Pandora lowers the notebook.

“No.”

“You mentioned the test today to see if I remembered.”

“No, I mentioned the test because I have to study for it.”

“But you looked directly at me.”

“I was talking to you.”

John makes a sound that suspiciously resembles a laugh disguised as a cough.

I ignore him.

Pandora goes back to her notebook.

The explanation is annoyingly reasonable.

There is a certification test.

She told me about it.

I wasn’t paying enough attention.

Today she mentioned it again because, apparently, human beings sometimes continue conversations without constructing elaborate psychological traps for their partners.

That’s embarrassing.

I take a sip of coffee.

Then something occurs to me.

“Wait.”

John closes his eyes.

Pandora doesn’t look up.

“You said you told me two weeks ago.”

“Yes.”

“And today you said *that* test.”

“Yes.”

“Which implies you expected me to remember it.”

Pandora slowly looks at me.

“So technically, whether you intended it or not, today became a test of whether I remembered the test.”

John puts the guitar down and rubs his face.

Pandora stares at me for several seconds.

Then she smiles.

Not a warm smile.

The kind of smile people use immediately before making decisions about another person’s future.

“You failed.”

I knew it.

I lean back on the couch, strangely satisfied.

John looks at me like I’ve completely misunderstood what just happened.

Maybe I have.

But here’s the important part: there *was* a test.

It wasn’t the test I thought it was, and technically Pandora wasn’t administering it, but I was nevertheless evaluated and found deficient.

That’s close enough.

Mr. Whiskers jumps back onto the coffee table and sits directly on John’s package of guitar strings.

John looks at him.

Mr. Whiskers looks at John.

Neither moves.

I point toward them.

“Now *that* is definitely a test.”

John tells me to shut up.

Pandora laughs.

And just like that, everything makes sense again.

Related Posts

• I Think John Mercer Is in on It Too
• I Think Karen Is Involved in This Somehow
• I Think She’s Hiding Something Behind That Ponytail

I’m staring at the coffee mug on the kitchen counter, and something’s wrong with it. Not damaged wrong. Not dirty wrong. Just wrong. I used it yesterday morning, washed it, and put it away exactly where it belongs. At least I’m almost certain I did. Yet there it is now, sitting near the corner of the counter with the handle pointing toward the refrigerator. I never leave the handle pointing toward the refrigerator. I know how ridiculous that sounds, but everyone has systems whether they admit it or not, and my system involves mug handles pointing to the right. That isn’t obsessive. That’s civilization.

Pandora says I’m staring at a coffee mug. I say I’m examining evidence. There’s a difference. She gives me the look she uses when she’s deciding whether participating in the conversation will make things better or considerably worse, then goes back to what she was doing. That reaction alone makes me suspicious. Yesterday I would have considered it normal Pandora behavior. Today there’s a displaced mug involved.

My first thought is John Mercer. I don’t particularly want my first thought to be John Mercer, but history has made that decision for me. John has demonstrated a remarkably flexible interpretation of personal property, especially when he believes he is being helpful. If a lamp moves three feet, John was improving the lighting. If something disappears from a drawer, John was organizing. If Pandora discovers one of her things somewhere it absolutely shouldn’t be, somehow John has an explanation involving efficiency. So if my mug has mysteriously migrated from the cabinet to the counter, John is at least a person of interest.

Pandora asks why John Mercer would move one coffee mug. That’s exactly the kind of question somebody asks before discovering that John Mercer has reorganized an entire kitchen according to a system nobody else understands. I tell her this. She reminds me that John isn’t here. I tell her that’s what makes it troubling.

Then Mr. Whiskers walks into the kitchen.

He stops beside the counter and looks up at the mug.

I look at him.

He looks at me.

This changes things.

Mr. Whiskers has always possessed the unnerving ability to appear precisely when something questionable is happening and then behave as though he has been investigating it for several hours. He sits beneath the counter, wraps his tail around his paws, and stares upward. I crouch beside him and follow his line of sight. Definitely the mug.

Pandora tells me he’s probably hoping there’s food on the counter.

Possible. Convenient, but possible.

Then I notice something else. The mug isn’t merely facing the wrong direction. It’s slightly farther back than I normally leave things. Maybe two inches. Three at most. Somebody didn’t just use it. Somebody deliberately positioned it.

Pandora asks how I could possibly know where a mug was sitting to within two inches.

That’s insulting.

Of course I know.

I live here.

Now I’m reconstructing yesterday. I had coffee in the morning. Pandora was in the kitchen later. Mrs. Jenkins stopped us in the hallway and talked to Pandora for a while. Karen was around at some point recently, although I’m refusing to drag Karen into this without evidence because I’ve learned that once Karen enters one of my theories, the theory develops branches. John Mercer has also been around enough lately that I can’t rule him out on principle. Dave, however, was at work, where Dave belongs, so for once my coworker has an airtight alibi.

I ask Pandora whether she used my mug.

She says she doesn’t remember.

Interesting.

I ask whether she moved my mug.

She says she doesn’t remember that either.

Very interesting.

She asks why I’m interrogating her about crockery.

Deflection.

I’m beginning to suspect the mug isn’t the mystery. The mug is evidence of the mystery.

Maybe Pandora was reorganizing the kitchen and moved it without telling me. That would explain the position but not why she can’t remember doing it. Maybe John used it when he was here previously and put it somewhere strange, then Pandora discovered it and moved it to the counter. Maybe Mrs. Jenkins distracted Pandora in the hallway while something was happening in the kitchen. Maybe Mr. Whiskers knows exactly what happened and is withholding information because he’s a cat and therefore legally accountable to nobody.

Mr. Whiskers suddenly jumps onto a chair.

I make a mental note of that.

Pandora notices me making a mental note of that and tells me not to make a mental note of that.

I make a second mental note.

The problem is that the longer I stare at the mug, the more certain I become that this isn’t my imagination. Something about it has definitely changed. I pick it up. I turn it around. I inspect the bottom. Nothing. I look inside. Empty. I hold it at eye level, which causes Pandora to leave the kitchen without saying anything.

That’s when I see it.

There’s a tiny chip near the bottom edge.

I knew it.

I call Pandora back.

She doesn’t come back.

I call slightly louder and announce that I’ve discovered physical evidence.

That gets her.

Pandora walks into the kitchen, looks at the chip, looks at me, and says, “Yes.”

Yes?

Apparently, yesterday evening Mr. Whiskers jumped onto the counter while Pandora was putting dishes away. She moved the mug before he could knock it over. It tapped against the edge of the sink, leaving the tiny chip. She set it on the far side of the counter because she wanted to check whether it was cracked before putting it back in the cabinet. Then she forgot about it.

I look at Mr. Whiskers.

Mr. Whiskers looks at me.

So I was right.

The mug had moved.

Pandora immediately says that absolutely none of the rest of my theory was right.

That’s beside the point.

John Mercer didn’t move it. Mrs. Jenkins wasn’t involved. Karen wasn’t gathering intelligence. Nobody was reorganizing the kitchen behind my back. There was no secret message, no conspiracy, and no coordinated attempt to destabilize my coffee-drinking routine. Mr. Whiskers jumped onto the counter, Pandora saved the mug, and the mug moved approximately three inches.

But it moved.

That’s the important part.

Pandora says the important part is that I somehow turned a chipped coffee mug into an investigation involving four people and a cat.

I tell her good investigators consider every possibility.

She tells me good investigators probably ask their wives what happened before accusing the neighbors of participating in an international mug conspiracy.

Fair.

Still, I can’t help feeling vindicated. I noticed something was wrong when nobody else did. My instincts told me that mug wasn’t where I’d left it, and my instincts were correct. Maybe the explanation wasn’t quite as complicated as I’d anticipated, but that’s hardly my fault. Evidence has to be followed wherever it leads.

I put the mug back in the cabinet with the handle pointing right.

Then I stop.

There are seven mugs in there.

Yesterday I’m almost positive there were eight.

I slowly turn toward Pandora.

She sees my face.

“No.”

I haven’t even said anything yet.

“No, Hal.”

Mr. Whiskers walks out of the kitchen.

Suspiciously.

Related Posts

• I Think John Mercer is Hiding Something in My Kitchen
• I’m Certain Pandora’s Coffee Came from Elsewhere
• I’m Starting to Suspect My Roommates of Collusion

I’m staring at the kitchen counter, trying to focus on the fact that John Mercer left his mug there again. This should not be important. People leave mugs on counters every day without triggering investigations. I understand that intellectually. Still, something about the mug bothers me, and it isn’t merely that John apparently believes dirty dishes eventually migrate to the sink on their own. It’s the whole kitchen. Pandora is standing near the refrigerator, quietly looking through something on her phone, and she has barely said anything for the last several minutes. We talked about dinner earlier and she seemed perfectly normal then, but now she’s giving me the distinct impression that she’s avoiding me. Or giving me space. Or waiting for me to leave. Those are three very different possibilities, which is exactly the problem.

Mr Whiskers is sitting several feet away, watching both of us. That doesn’t help. There is something uniquely unsettling about being silently observed by an orange cat when you’re already suspicious of everyone else in the room. He isn’t grooming himself. He isn’t sleeping. He isn’t asking for food. He’s just sitting there with his paws together, staring at Pandora, then at me, then back at Pandora. I know cats do this. I also know Mr Whiskers, and there’s a difference between his normal staring and whatever this is. His normal stare says, I would like some of what you’re eating. This stare says, I have information.

My mind drifts back to something that happened at work. Karen called me over to her desk earlier and asked whether everything was okay at home. It was probably an innocent question. In fact, I’m almost certain it was an innocent question. She’s my coworker, we talk, and apparently I’ve been distracted enough lately for other people to notice. I told Pandora about it when I got home, and she laughed before asking what I’d told Karen. At the time, I thought nothing of it. Now, standing in the kitchen with John’s abandoned mug and Mr Whiskers conducting surveillance from the floor, I’m reconsidering the entire exchange.

Why did Pandora want to know what I told Karen?

I look at Mr Whiskers.

He looks at Pandora.

Pandora looks into the refrigerator.

Interesting.

Maybe John’s mug isn’t evidence of anything. Maybe Pandora isn’t acting strangely. Maybe Karen was simply making conversation. Any reasonable person could look at these facts and conclude that absolutely nothing unusual is happening. Unfortunately, I am currently the only person here willing to investigate the alternative.

Pandora finally closes the refrigerator and asks whether I want chicken or pasta for dinner. I tell her either is fine, because I don’t want her to know that I’m observing her. She says, “Okay,” and goes back to her phone. Mr Whiskers immediately gets up and follows her into the living room.

There it is.

I knew it.

I follow them, although I make a point of doing it casually. This turns out to be surprisingly difficult because there is no natural way to casually follow your girlfriend and your cat while pretending you aren’t following either of them. Pandora sits on the couch. Mr Whiskers jumps up beside her. She scratches him behind the ears. He begins purring.

That should settle the matter. Cat likes woman. Woman pets cat. Case closed.

Except Pandora has been paying considerably more attention to Mr Whiskers lately. I’ve noticed it before but never connected it to anything. She gives him treats when she thinks I’m not looking. She lets him sit beside her while she works. Yesterday I saw her carrying him toward the bedroom while whispering something to him.

At least, I think she was whispering. She might have been saying, “Who’s a handsome boy?”

But that’s exactly what you’d say if you didn’t want anyone to know you were discussing something important.

I sit in the chair across from them and pretend to check my phone. Mr Whiskers looks at me.

Then he looks at Pandora.

Then he slowly closes his eyes.

I nearly drop the phone.

Was that a signal?

No. Obviously not. Cats blink. There are scientific explanations for this. I’m pretty sure slow blinking is supposed to mean affection or trust. But trust between whom? Me and Mr Whiskers? Pandora and Mr Whiskers? Mr Whiskers and whatever organization he now represents?

Pandora catches me staring at him. “What?”

“Nothing.”

“You’re staring at the cat.”

“I’m looking in his general direction.”

“You’ve been looking in his general direction for five minutes.”

That’s the sort of highly specific observation someone makes when they’re keeping track of your behavior.

I decide not to mention that.

Instead, I start thinking about John. He has been behaving normally, which suddenly seems suspicious in itself. John has a remarkable ability to appear precisely when I’m in the middle of figuring something out, say something completely ordinary, and derail my entire train of thought. Yesterday I was trying to remember whether Pandora had gone somewhere after work when John walked into the room and asked if anybody wanted pizza. Five minutes later, I was comparing toppings instead of reconstructing Pandora’s movements.

Coincidence?

Probably.

Effective?

Absolutely.

And now there’s the mug.

I glance toward the kitchen.

Still there.

It suddenly occurs to me that perhaps I’ve been looking at this backward. Maybe John isn’t coordinating anything. Maybe Pandora isn’t hiding anything. Maybe Mr Whiskers is the common denominator.

The idea sounds ridiculous for approximately three seconds.

Then it begins making an alarming amount of sense.

Mr Whiskers is present for nearly everything. When Pandora is on her phone, he’s nearby. When John comes into the room, Mr Whiskers watches him. When I’m trying to have a serious conversation, Mr Whiskers inevitably jumps onto something, knocks something over, demands food, or inserts himself directly into the situation. He has unrestricted access to the apartment. Nobody questions where he goes. Nobody asks what he’s doing. He can sit underneath a table during an entire conversation and everyone considers that normal.

It is, frankly, the perfect arrangement.

I look at him again.

He’s asleep.

Convenient.

Pandora notices me staring. “Hal.”

“What?”

“Leave the cat alone.”

“I’m not doing anything.”

“You’re squinting at him.”

“I’m thinking.”

“That’s what worries me.”

She goes back to her phone, and I lean deeper into the chair. That comment was probably a joke. Pandora makes jokes. We joke with each other all the time. There is absolutely no reason to interpret it as evidence that she knows I’m getting close to something.

Mr Whiskers opens one eye.

I freeze.

He closes it again.

Okay.

Now I’m convinced.

The next morning at work, Karen asks whether I ever figured out why I’d been so distracted the day before. I consider telling her about Mr Whiskers but decide against it. If Karen is innocent, she’ll think I’ve lost my mind. If Karen is involved, telling her would compromise the investigation. Either way, silence seems strategically sound.

“You okay?” she asks.

“Perfectly.”

Karen stares at me for a moment. “You have that look again.”

“What look?”

“The one where you think you’ve figured something out.”

That stops me.

“How do you know that look?”

She laughs and walks away.

I remain at my desk.

Well.

That’s interesting.

By the time I get home, I’ve constructed a working theory. I’m not saying Mr Whiskers is deliberately involved in anything. That would be absurd. He’s a cat. He lacks the organizational skills necessary for a conspiracy. He once got trapped behind the shower curtain for twenty minutes.

But I’m no longer convinced he’s irrelevant.

I open the apartment door and find Pandora on the couch reading. John is in the kitchen. Everything looks completely ordinary.

Then I notice Mr Whiskers.

He’s sitting beside John’s mug.

The same mug.

John apparently still hasn’t washed it.

Mr Whiskers places one paw against the handle and looks directly at me.

I stop in the doorway.

Pandora glances up from her book. “What now?”

I point at the counter.

She looks at Mr Whiskers, then at the mug, then back at me.

“Hal, he’s a cat.”

“That’s exactly what everyone keeps assuming.”

Pandora stares at me for several seconds before lowering her book and laughing.

Mr Whiskers knocks the mug onto the floor.

John shouts from the kitchen.

Pandora laughs harder.

I say nothing.

Because everybody else sees a cat knocking over a mug.

I see destruction of evidence.

Related Posts

• I Just Realized Mr Whiskers Has Been Watching John Very Closely
• I Knew Something Was Off the Way Pandora Was Eating Cereal
• I’m Certain Pandora’s Coffee Came from Elsewhere

I’m sitting on the couch watching John Mercer fiddle with his phone, and I’m beginning to understand why some people throw electronics into lakes. He’s been trying to order a new charger for what feels like several hours, although realistically it’s probably been twenty minutes. The problem is that John doesn’t simply buy things. John researches them. He compares them. He reads reviews written by people who apparently have very strong opinions about electrical cables. Then he closes the app, opens it again, searches for the exact same charger, and begins the entire process over.

Pandora walks through the living room with her purse over her shoulder and says she’s going out for coffee.

I look at the cup sitting on the table beside me.

Then I look at her.

“We have coffee.”

“I know.”

That’s all she says.

The door closes behind her.

Interesting.

Mr. Whiskers is stretched across my lap, purring with the serenity of an animal who contributes absolutely nothing financially to this household yet somehow experiences less stress than everyone who does. I scratch behind his ears while watching the door.

“Did that seem strange to you?”

Mr. Whiskers continues purring.

John doesn’t look up from his phone. “What?”

“Pandora.”

“What about her?”

“She went out for coffee.”

John finally looks at me. “People do that.”

“We have coffee.”

John stares at me for a moment, then returns to his charger search.

Nobody is taking this seriously.

I start thinking about Pandora’s behavior over the last few days. She has seemed distracted. Maybe distant. Yesterday I asked what she wanted for dinner and she said, “Whatever you want,” which sounds cooperative until you understand that no human being in a committed relationship has ever said those words without there being additional information hidden somewhere underneath them.

Maybe she’s stressed about work. That would make sense. Pandora gets absorbed in things sometimes, and I know better than to interpret every quiet moment as evidence of a crisis.

I do know better.

Knowing better and actually doing better are apparently two separate departments in my brain.

John sighs dramatically at his phone.

“What now?”

“This one has twelve thousand reviews.”

“That sounds promising.”

“Four point six stars.”

“Buy it.”

“But the other one has four point seven.”

I stare at him.

He stares at the screen.

Maybe Pandora didn’t leave because of me. Maybe she left because John Mercer has transformed our living room into the headquarters of an international charger procurement operation.

That possibility comforts me for approximately thirty seconds.

Then I remember last weekend.

Pandora was quiet when we were out together. I noticed it then but didn’t say anything because John was talking about something—I don’t remember what—and Pandora kept checking her phone. At the time I assumed it was work. Now I’m wondering if she was avoiding a conversation with me.

Mr. Whiskers shifts on my lap.

“What?”

His eyes remain closed.

“You noticed it too.”

John looks over. “Are you talking to the cat?”

“No.”

I wait until John looks away.

“What did you notice?”

Mr. Whiskers yawns.

That could mean anything.

A few minutes later, there’s movement outside the window. Mrs. Jenkins is tending to something near her plants. Mr. Whiskers immediately climbs off my lap, jumps onto the windowsill, and stares outside.

There.

That’s exactly the sort of thing I’ve been noticing.

Mrs. Jenkins appears. Mr. Whiskers goes to the window.

Coincidence?

Probably.

But technically I don’t know that.

I get up and stand beside him. Mrs. Jenkins is moving between several pots with a watering can. Nothing unusual. No suspicious visitors. No packages changing hands. No coded signals that I can identify.

Mr. Whiskers watches intently.

“You know something.”

John sighs behind me.

I turn around. “What?”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You sighed.”

“I’m buying the charger.”

Finally.

“Which one?”

“The four-point-six.”

“Why?”

“Ships tomorrow.”

A rational decision. I’m genuinely impressed.

Then my phone buzzes.

It’s Pandora.

**Getting some quiet for a little while. Be home soon. Love you.**

I read the message twice.

Quiet.

She went somewhere else for quiet.

I slowly turn toward John.

He’s no longer talking.

He’s sitting peacefully on the couch ordering a charger.

Mr. Whiskers is sitting peacefully on the windowsill watching Mrs. Jenkins water flowers.

The apartment is remarkably quiet.

Except for me.

I think back over the last several days. Pandora seemed distracted, so I asked whether something was wrong. She said no. I asked again later. She still said no. Yesterday I asked if she was sure. Last night I mentioned that she seemed quieter than usual. This morning I asked if she was upset with me because she put her coffee cup down harder than normal.

At the time, these seemed like reasonable observations.

Taken together, they begin to look less reasonable.

I sit back down.

John glances at me.

“What?”

“I think I might be the problem.”

John lowers his phone.

He doesn’t say anything, which is probably wise.

“I mean, not *the* problem,” I clarify. “Obviously there could still be other factors.”

John raises his phone again.

“But maybe a contributing factor.”

He nods.

That nod bothers me.

“How long have you thought that?”

“I’m staying out of this.”

“You nodded very quickly.”

“I didn’t nod.”

“You absolutely nodded.”

Mr. Whiskers turns around on the windowsill and looks at me.

Now both of them are doing it.

I pick up my phone and read Pandora’s message again. *Getting some quiet for a little while.*

Maybe that’s all this is.

Maybe Pandora isn’t hiding anything. Maybe she isn’t avoiding me because something mysterious happened. Maybe she’s been stressed, and every time she gets quiet I begin investigating the silence like it’s evidence from a crime scene.

That would explain quite a lot, actually.

It would explain why she looked irritated this morning when I asked if her choice of cereal meant something.

In retrospect, that question may have been unnecessary.

I send her a message.

**Enjoy your coffee. I’ll see you when you get home. Love you too.**

Then I put my phone down.

There.

Healthy.

Normal.

Emotionally mature.

John looks impressed.

Or maybe relieved.

For the next ten minutes, I don’t analyze anything. I don’t ask John questions. I don’t interrogate Mr. Whiskers. I don’t monitor Mrs. Jenkins. I simply sit on the couch and enjoy the silence.

It’s actually nice.

Maybe I’ve learned something today.

Maybe sometimes there isn’t a mystery. Sometimes Pandora just wants coffee somewhere other than our kitchen. Sometimes John Mercer just needs a charger. Sometimes Mrs. Jenkins is simply watering her plants. Sometimes Mr. Whiskers is looking out the window because he’s a cat.

I feel surprisingly peaceful.

Then Mr. Whiskers stands.

His ears perk forward.

He stares intensely through the window toward Mrs. Jenkins’ plants.

I follow his gaze.

Mrs. Jenkins bends down, reaches behind one of the large flowerpots, and pulls out a small metal box.

I sit forward.

John notices.

“No.”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You’re doing the face.”

“What face?”

“The conspiracy face.”

Mrs. Jenkins looks around.

Then she carries the box inside.

I slowly stand.

John points at me.

“Hal.”

“I’m just looking.”

“Sit down.”

“She looked around first.”

“People look around.”

“Not like that.”

“You literally just admitted you’re the problem.”

“I said I might be *a contributing factor*. That’s completely different.”

Mr. Whiskers looks up at me.

I look down at him.

Then we both look toward Mrs. Jenkins’ place.

I knew that cat saw something.

So yes, maybe I’ve been overthinking Pandora.

Maybe I need to give her more space.

Maybe I should stop treating every ordinary change in human behavior like the opening stages of an elaborate conspiracy.

That’s growth.

But none of that explains the metal box.

And I think we need to be very careful about throwing out perfectly good instincts just because I happened to misuse them several dozen times before.

John tells me to sit down.

I sit down.

For now.

Mr. Whiskers stays at the window.

Good.

At least one of us is still on the case.

Related Posts

• I Think My Cat Knows More Than He’s Letting On
• I Caught John Mercer Staring at Pandora’s Poetry Again
• I Think Pandora’s Building Some Kind of Social Intelligence Network

I’m sitting in the living room watching Mr Whiskers groom one paw with the kind of concentration I usually reserve for problems that don’t exist yet. Pandora is curled up on the other end of the couch scrolling through her phone, and somewhere behind me John Mercer is opening and closing kitchen cabinets. Normally, none of this would bother me. Except John has opened the same cabinet three times.

I turn slightly and look toward the kitchen. The cabinet opens. John looks inside. The cabinet closes. A few seconds pass, and the cabinet opens again. Same cabinet. I look down at Mr Whiskers. “You seeing this?” Mr Whiskers continues licking his paw. Fine. Apparently I’m handling this investigation alone.

John closes the cabinet and opens the refrigerator. “You looking for something?” I ask.

“Nope.”

That stops me. “You’ve opened that cabinet three times.”

John looks at the cabinet, then at me. “Have I?”

“Yes.”

“Huh.”

Then he walks away. Huh? That’s his explanation? I watch him cross the living room and disappear down the hall like a man who hasn’t just been caught repeatedly inspecting the same cabinet for reasons he refuses to explain.

Pandora glances up from her phone. “What?”

“Nothing.”

“You’re staring at John again.”

“I wasn’t staring.”

“You turned your entire body to watch him walk down the hall.”

That’s technically true, but I don’t appreciate the implication. I turn back toward the television and try to forget about it. Maybe John was looking for something. Maybe he forgot which cabinet he had already checked. Maybe he’s tired. There are dozens of perfectly reasonable explanations for opening the same cabinet three times.

Four, apparently.

John has returned. He walks straight into the kitchen and opens it again. I slowly look at Pandora. She doesn’t react. That’s what bothers me. Nobody reacts. John Mercer has now opened the same kitchen cabinet four times in less than ten minutes, and apparently I’m the only person in this household who finds that noteworthy.

“John.”

He looks over.

“What is in that cabinet?”

“Cups.”

“I know what’s in the cabinet.”

“Then why’d you ask?”

I stare at him. He stares at me. Mr Whiskers stops grooming himself long enough to stare at both of us. John takes out a glass and fills it with water.

Interesting. Very interesting.

“You wanted a glass?”

“Yeah.”

“So the other three times?”

John pauses. “I forgot what I was looking for.”

There it is. The oldest excuse in the book.

Pandora laughs. I look at her. “What’s funny?”

“You.”

“I’m noticing a pattern.”

“You’re watching a man get a glass of water.”

“After three reconnaissance missions.”

John takes his water and walks out of the kitchen. Pandora shakes her head and goes back to her phone. Nobody takes these things seriously until it’s too late.

The cabinet incident wouldn’t bother me nearly as much if it were isolated, but it isn’t. I’ve been noticing other things about John lately. Yesterday he came into the living room, picked up the television remote, looked at it for several seconds, and put it back down without changing the channel. Why? Tuesday, he stood near the front door with his shoes on for almost five minutes before leaving. Five minutes. What was he waiting for? And earlier this week I caught him looking through the refrigerator for something, only to close it and announce, “Never mind.”

Never mind what?

These aren’t random events anymore. They’re a pattern.

I mention this to Pandora. She doesn’t even look up. “People forget things, Hal.”

“Four times?”

“Yes.”

“In the same cabinet?”

“Yes.”

“Within ten minutes?”

Now she looks at me. “Yes.”

I don’t like how quickly she answered that. Maybe Pandora already knows about John’s behavior. That possibility hadn’t occurred to me. I study her for a moment.

She notices. “Don’t.”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You’re about to.”

That’s another interesting development. Apparently Pandora can now predict what I’m going to say before I say it. I file that away mentally.

Mr Whiskers jumps down from the couch and trots toward the kitchen. He stops directly in front of the cabinet John kept opening and sits.

Oh, come on.

I lean forward. Pandora sees me.

“No.”

“The cat went straight to the cabinet.”

“He wants treats.”

“Are the treats in that cabinet?”

“Yes.”

I hadn’t considered that. Actually, that explains quite a lot. Except John wasn’t getting treats. Unless he was checking them. Why would John be checking Mr Whiskers’ treats?

I stand up. Pandora lowers her phone. “Where are you going?”

“Kitchen.”

“Why?”

“I’m thirsty.”

She gives me a look. I walk into the kitchen and open the cabinet. Cups. Exactly as John claimed. I move a few things around. Nothing unusual. Mugs, glasses, Mr Whiskers’ treats, and a container whose lid hasn’t matched the container itself since approximately 2019. No secret documents. No mysterious devices. No coded messages. I close the cabinet, then open it again. Just to be thorough. Still nothing.

When I turn around, John is standing behind me. I nearly jump out of my skin.

“What are you doing?”

“Getting water,” I say.

John looks at the glass already sitting beside the sink. Then at me. Then at the cabinet. “Okay.”

He walks away.

That “okay” bothers me. It wasn’t a normal okay. It was an I know exactly what you’re doing okay.

I return to the couch. Pandora is smiling.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“You’re smiling.”

“Am I?”

Now she’s doing it too. This is spreading.

Later that afternoon, I notice another pattern. Every time John enters the living room, he looks toward the window before sitting down. Not for long. Just a glance. Once could be nothing. Twice could be coincidence. Five times? That’s surveillance.

I wait until John leaves the room and walk over to the window. Mrs Jenkins is outside next door tending to something near her front steps. She looks up. I immediately step away from the window.

Interesting.

John keeps checking the window. Mrs Jenkins happens to be outside. Coincidence? Probably. But “probably” is doing a lot of work there.

Then something else happens. John returns to the living room. He looks toward the window. He sits down. Mr Whiskers jumps onto the couch beside him. John scratches Mr Whiskers behind the ears. Mr Whiskers begins purring. I stare at them. John notices.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“You’ve been saying ‘nothing’ a lot today.”

“So have you.”

“When?”

“Kitchen.”

John looks confused. Exactly how someone would look if they were trying to appear confused.

Pandora gets up and heads toward the kitchen. As she passes me, she pats my shoulder. “You need a hobby.”

“I have hobbies.”

“Watching John isn’t a hobby.”

“That depends on what John is doing.”

John sighs.

That’s another thing. He’s been sighing more. I hadn’t noticed until now.

I start counting. Over the next hour, John sighs six times, checks his phone four times, looks toward the window twice, goes into the kitchen three times, and opens that cabinet once. At this point, the pattern is undeniable.

I grab a notebook. John looks over. “What are you writing?”

“Nothing.”

Pandora laughs from the kitchen. John shakes his head. I write that down too.

7:14 p.m. — John asks what I’m writing.

7:15 p.m. — John attempts to appear unconcerned.

7:15 p.m. — Pandora laughs for unexplained reasons.

Mr Whiskers jumps onto the coffee table. I add another line.

7:16 p.m. — Cat becomes involved.

Now we’re getting somewhere.

Eventually John gets up, walks into the kitchen, and opens the cabinet again. I immediately sit forward. He reaches inside and takes out the bag of cat treats. Mr Whiskers bolts toward him. John gives him two, then looks at me.

“There.”

“There what?”

“That’s what I’ve been looking for all day.”

I stare at him. “The cat treats?”

“Yeah. Pandora moved them.”

Pandora calls from the kitchen, “I moved them six inches!”

John shrugs. “I couldn’t find them.”

I slowly lower my notebook. That explains the cabinet. It also explains Mr Whiskers sitting in front of it. And John repeatedly looking around the room could simply be John trying to remember where Pandora had moved something that had apparently traveled the enormous distance of six inches.

Fine. One mystery solved.

But the window?

“What about the window?”

John looks at me. “What about it?”

“You keep looking outside.”

“My car’s parked under a tree.”

“So?”

“Birds.”

I wait for more. There isn’t more.

“You’re worried about birds?”

“I’m worried about what birds do to cars.”

Okay. Also reasonable. Annoyingly reasonable.

I look down at my notebook. Most of my evidence has collapsed in under thirty seconds. Pandora walks back into the living room, sees the notebook, and takes it from me before I can stop her. She reads silently until she reaches the final entry.

7:16 p.m. — Cat becomes involved.

Pandora starts laughing so hard she has to sit down. John takes the notebook from her and reads it. He looks at me, then at Mr Whiskers, then back at me.

“You tracked my sighing?”

“Patterns matter.”

“I sighed because you were watching me.”

I hadn’t considered that.

Mr Whiskers jumps onto John’s lap. John gives him another treat. Pandora is still laughing. I lean back into the couch and reconsider the day’s evidence. Apparently John wasn’t hiding anything. He couldn’t find the cat treats. He was checking the window because he didn’t want birds decorating his car. He kept checking his phone because normal human beings apparently do that. And the sighing was, according to John, a direct consequence of living with me.

Every individual explanation makes sense. Which is precisely what bothers me. Because when every suspicious behavior has a perfectly reasonable explanation, eventually you have to consider the possibility that all those reasonable explanations are part of the pattern.

I look at John. John looks at me. Then he deliberately opens the cabinet. Closes it. Opens it again. Closes it. Opens it a third time.

Pandora starts laughing. John smiles. Mr Whiskers meows.

I reach for my notebook.

John immediately stops smiling.

Exactly.

Now who’s noticing patterns?

Related Posts

• I Think My Cat Knows More Than He’s Letting On
• I Knew Something Was Off When Mr. Whiskers Slept In
• I Knew Something Was Off About Mrs Jenkins’ Trash Cans

I’m sitting on the couch, staring at Pandora while she’s completely engrossed in her phone. Mr Whiskers is sprawled across my lap, purring softly as he wedges his head into the crook of my arm like he pays rent here, and John Mercer is in the kitchen rummaging through the refrigerator for leftovers he will almost certainly claim he was “just checking.” The television is humming quietly in the background, Pandora is scrolling, Mr Whiskers is vibrating against my leg, and everything should feel perfectly normal.

Except Pandora keeps checking her phone.

I noticed it about twenty minutes ago. Or maybe fifteen. I’m not timing her or anything. That would be weird. But she has definitely looked at that phone more often than usual. Every few minutes the screen lights up, she glances down, taps something, and goes back to whatever she was doing. At first I assumed it was work. Then I wondered if Karen had texted her, except Karen is my coworker and there’s no particular reason she should suddenly be conducting an extended text conversation with Pandora. Dave crossed my mind too, but that makes even less sense. Dave works with me. Why would Dave be texting Pandora?

Actually, that’s a very good question.

Mr Whiskers shifts on my lap and looks up at me.

“You seeing this?” I whisper.

He blinks.

Exactly.

I try watching television again, but now that I’ve noticed Pandora checking her phone, I can’t stop noticing Pandora checking her phone. It’s one of those things where once you see it, you can’t unsee it. Like a crooked picture frame. Or John Mercer putting an empty milk carton back in the refrigerator.

John walks back into the living room carrying a plate of something I don’t remember buying.

“Everything okay?” he asks.

“Perfect,” I say.

He looks at me for a second.

Then at Pandora.

Then back at me.

Interesting.

John sits down as if nothing unusual has happened, which is exactly what someone would do if something unusual had happened and he didn’t want me to know about it.

Pandora’s phone lights up again.

She looks at it.

I look at her.

She looks up and catches me looking at her.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

She stares at me for another second and goes back to her phone.

That was suspicious.

Or maybe I made it suspicious by staring at her like a detective who had just discovered the murder weapon. Hard to tell.

Mr Whiskers begins kneading my leg with his paws.

I look down at him.

“You’re unusually calm about this.”

He continues kneading.

Of course he is.

I decide that maybe Pandora is simply bored. People check their phones when they’re bored. I check my phone when I’m bored. John checks his phone constantly, although half the time I’m convinced he’s just opening the weather app because he doesn’t know what else to do with himself.

Still, Pandora isn’t merely checking her phone.

She’s checking it.

There’s a difference.

I can’t explain the difference, but I know one exists.

The screen lights up again. Pandora glances at it and smiles.

There.

That changes everything.

Someone sent something that made her smile.

I immediately run through the possibilities. Work? Unlikely. Nobody smiles at work messages. A friend? Possible. Some ridiculous video? Also possible. A secret international intelligence network coordinating activities through encrypted messaging applications?

Statistically less likely.

But not impossible.

John looks over.

“You’re doing that thing again.”

“What thing?”

“The staring thing.”

“I’m watching television.”

“The television is over there.”

I look toward the television.

He’s right.

That doesn’t prove anything.

I reposition Mr Whiskers and try to concentrate on the show, but my brain has already begun constructing a timeline. Pandora checked her phone at least four times. Maybe five. She smiled once. John noticed me noticing her. John then attempted to distract me by pointing out that I wasn’t watching television.

That’s three pieces of evidence.

Granted, none of them are evidence of anything.

But they’re still pieces.

Then I remember something from work. Earlier this week, Karen asked me whether Pandora was doing okay. At the time, I assumed she was just being polite. But what if she already knew something? And yesterday Dave told me I looked tired.

Why would Dave say that?

Because I looked tired, obviously.

Unless he was checking whether I’d been awake late enough to notice something.

I sit up slightly.

Mr Whiskers gives me an irritated look because my movement has disturbed his position.

And suddenly I remember the way Dave changed the subject at work when I mentioned Pandora had been distracted lately. I thought nothing of it at the time. Now I’m thinking something of it.

A lot of something.

Maybe Karen knows something. Maybe Dave knows Karen knows something. Maybe John knows that Dave knows Karen knows something.

Pandora’s phone lights up again.

She picks it up.

Mr Whiskers lifts his head.

I freeze.

Pandora types something.

Mr Whiskers jumps off my lap.

I stare at him.

He walks directly toward Pandora.

Oh, come on.

Now even the cat is involved.

Mr Whiskers jumps onto the couch beside her and rubs his head against her arm. Pandora scratches behind his ears without taking her eyes off the phone.

There it is.

Communication.

I don’t know what kind, obviously, but something just happened.

“You two seem awfully coordinated today,” I say.

Pandora looks at me.

“Me and the cat?”

I nod.

John slowly lowers his fork.

Pandora looks at Mr Whiskers, then back at me.

“He wanted attention.”

“Convenient.”

“For whom?”

Good question.

I hadn’t gotten that far yet.

Pandora shakes her head and returns to her phone. John continues eating, although I notice he’s doing it considerably more quietly now. Probably because he’s listening.

I start thinking about Mrs Jenkins next door. She hasn’t done anything suspicious today, which in itself feels slightly suspicious considering how often she accidentally ends up involved in these things. Maybe that’s the point. Maybe everyone has finally realized I’ve been paying attention and Mrs Jenkins has deliberately stayed out of sight.

That’s actually pretty clever.

I glance toward the wall separating our place from hers.

Nothing.

Too quiet.

Meanwhile, Mr Whiskers is sitting beside Pandora staring directly at me.

I stare back.

He blinks once.

I blink once.

He blinks again.

I don’t.

Nice try.

The entire situation is becoming clearer now. Pandora has been checking her phone. John has been pretending nothing unusual is happening. Karen asked about Pandora at work. Dave changed the subject when I mentioned her. Mrs Jenkins has remained suspiciously absent. And Mr Whiskers has abandoned my lap to sit beside Pandora at precisely the moment she received another message.

Individually, these things mean absolutely nothing.

Together?

They also probably mean absolutely nothing.

But that isn’t the point.

The point is that I’m the only person who seems to be noticing them.

Pandora’s phone buzzes again.

I watch her pick it up.

She reads the message.

Then she laughs.

Not smiles.

Laughs.

That’s it.

“Who keeps texting you?”

Pandora looks up.

For the first time all evening, John Mercer stops chewing.

Even Mr Whiskers turns toward me.

Pandora holds up her phone.

“My sister.”

I stare at her.

“Your sister?”

“She keeps sending me pictures.”

Pandora turns the phone around.

There is a photograph of a dog wearing sunglasses.

I look at Pandora.

I look at John.

I look at Mr Whiskers.

Mr Whiskers looks at the dog.

Then he looks at me.

I know what everyone expects me to believe.

Pandora has simply been texting her sister. John Mercer was simply hungry. Karen was simply making conversation at work. Dave simply thought I looked tired. Mrs Jenkins is simply minding her own business next door. And Mr Whiskers is simply a cat who moved from one side of the couch to the other.

It’s a perfectly reasonable explanation.

Almost too reasonable.

I lean back against the couch.

Pandora goes back to her phone. John goes back to eating. Mr Whiskers curls up beside her as if nothing happened.

Nobody says another word about it.

And somehow, that bothers me more than anything.

Because either I’ve spent the last half hour constructing an elaborate conspiracy out of a woman texting her sister and a cat changing seats…

…or everyone in this apartment has gotten very good at covering their tracks.

I look at Mr Whiskers.

He closes his eyes.

Yeah.

I’m definitely the only one who notices.

Related Posts

• I Think John Mercer Is in on It Too
• I Think My Cat Knows More Than He’s Letting On
• I Think Our Cat Is in Cahoots with Mrs Jenkins’

I’m making coffee, and it should be a completely normal morning. Pandora is still asleep, Mr. Whiskers is sitting outside the bedroom complaining like he hasn’t eaten since the Eisenhower administration, and John Mercer is nowhere to be seen. None of this should bother me. Pandora occasionally sleeps late, Mr. Whiskers considers an empty section of his food bowl a humanitarian crisis, and John is perfectly capable of leaving the apartment without filing an itinerary with me. Still, something feels off. When I walked into the living room, John’s backpack was sitting beside the front door even though John himself was gone.

I pour my coffee and stare at the backpack. Obviously, there are reasonable explanations. Maybe John went downstairs for something. Maybe he went to his car. Maybe he forgot the backpack. Those are all considerably more likely than whatever my brain is preparing to suggest, which is precisely why I immediately start examining the situation like I’ve arrived at a crime scene.

Then I notice Pandora’s phone on the coffee table.

It’s on silent.

That shouldn’t mean anything. People put their phones on silent all the time. I put mine on silent whenever I don’t want anyone calling me, which, now that I think about it, is practically the definition of why phones have a silent setting. But Pandora usually leaves hers on vibrate. More importantly, why is her phone in the living room if she’s asleep in the bedroom?

I look at John’s backpack again.

Then Pandora’s phone.

Then the backpack.

Something happened here.

Mr. Whiskers strolls into the living room and sits beside the backpack.

Great. Now there’s a witness.

“Do you know something?” I ask him.

Mr. Whiskers looks at me, looks at the backpack, and begins licking his shoulder.

That is not a denial.

I remember something from last night. Pandora and John were talking quietly in the kitchen while I was looking for something to eat. I hadn’t thought anything of it at the time because people are allowed to have conversations without inviting me, despite how suspicious that policy now seems. When I walked into the kitchen, however, they stopped talking.

At least, I think they stopped talking.

Maybe they had simply finished talking.

No. They stopped.

I remember John looking at Pandora, Pandora looking at John, and then both of them looking at me. John asked whether I had found the crackers I was looking for. Pandora smiled. I said yes. At the time, that seemed like an entirely normal interaction.

It no longer seems normal.

They were coordinating something.

I take my coffee to the couch and begin reconstructing the previous evening. John had been checking his phone more than usual. Pandora disappeared into the home office for about twenty minutes. Later, I found the two of them in the kitchen. Then John vanished sometime during the night while leaving his backpack behind. Now Pandora is sleeping unusually late and her phone is sitting on silent in the living room.

Individually, these facts mean absolutely nothing.

Together, they mean slightly more than absolutely nothing.

Which is enough for me.

Mr. Whiskers jumps onto the couch beside me and stares toward the bedroom.

“You noticed it too.”

He yawns.

Exactly.

I’m beginning to think Pandora and John were working on something together last night, and whatever it was, they deliberately kept me out of it. Maybe Pandora needed John’s help with something. That would be reasonable. Maybe John needed Pandora’s help. Also reasonable. Maybe they were planning something that involved me.

Less reasonable.

Much more interesting.

I start thinking about the possibilities. My birthday isn’t coming up. There’s no anniversary I’ve forgotten, unless there is, in which case I have a considerably larger problem. Nobody has mentioned a trip. Nothing in the apartment is broken badly enough to require a secret committee. So what exactly requires whispered conversations, abandoned backpacks, silent phones, and suspicious kitchen meetings?

Then I notice a folded piece of paper sticking halfway out from underneath John’s backpack.

There it is.

Evidence.

I don’t touch it because I have principles. Also because if I touch it and John catches me, I’ll have to explain why I was investigating a backpack before eight in the morning.

Instead, I lean sideways.

There are words written on the paper.

I lean farther.

Mr. Whiskers watches me.

“Don’t judge me.”

He absolutely judges me.

I can make out what looks like a list. There are several lines, maybe five or six, with something crossed out near the bottom. I can’t read the words from where I’m sitting, but lists are rarely innocent. Grocery lists are innocent. To-do lists can be innocent. Secret lists underneath abandoned backpacks following whispered midnight conversations are something else entirely.

That’s when Pandora walks into the living room.

I straighten so quickly I nearly spill my coffee.

She looks at me, then at Mr. Whiskers, then at John’s backpack.

“What are you doing?”

“Nothing.”

Pandora narrows her eyes.

I sip my coffee.

Mr. Whiskers abandons me immediately and walks over to her.

Traitor.

Pandora picks up her phone from the coffee table and checks it. “John texted?”

Interesting choice of words.

“You tell me.”

She looks at me again. “Why would I tell you if John texted my phone?”

A tactical mistake on my part.

Before I can recover, the front door opens and John walks in carrying a paper bag and a cardboard drink tray. He stops when he sees me sitting on the couch.

Pandora looks at John.

John looks at Pandora.

There it is again.

The look.

“I got it,” John says.

Pandora smiles. “Perfect.”

I slowly put down my coffee.

“What did you get?”

Neither of them answers immediately.

That’s all the confirmation I need.

“I knew it.”

John looks confused. “Knew what?”

“You two are working together.”

Pandora folds her arms. “Working together on what?”

“That’s what I’m trying to figure out.”

John looks at Pandora. Pandora looks at John. Then they both start laughing, which is exactly what people do when their operation has been compromised and they’re desperately trying to maintain plausible deniability.

John sets the paper bag on the table and pulls out breakfast sandwiches.

Pandora reaches inside and takes one.

I stare at them.

John holds one toward me. “You want yours?”

I don’t take it.

“My what?”

“Your breakfast.”

Pandora is still smiling. “You complained yesterday that nobody ever brings you breakfast.”

I look at the bag.

Then at John.

Then at Pandora.

Then at the folded paper underneath John’s backpack.

John notices where I’m looking and picks it up.

It’s a breakfast order.

My name is on it.

Extra bacon.

For several seconds, nobody says anything.

Mr. Whiskers jumps onto the couch and sniffs the bag.

I take my sandwich.

“So,” Pandora says, “what exactly did you think we were doing?”

“Nothing.”

John grins. “You said we were working together.”

“I meant on breakfast.”

“You didn’t know about breakfast.”

“I suspected breakfast.”

Pandora laughs.

I unwrap my sandwich and retreat into the safest available position, which is eating something while refusing to elaborate.

Fine.

Maybe I got a little carried away.

Maybe Pandora’s phone was on silent because she forgot to take it to bed. Maybe John left his backpack because he walked out to get breakfast. Maybe their secret conversation last night was just Pandora giving him our orders so they could surprise me.

All perfectly reasonable explanations.

Still, I saw the way they looked at each other when John walked through that door.

And Mr. Whiskers has been staring at the breakfast bag for almost three minutes.

So I’m willing to admit that I may have misunderstood the situation.

But I’m keeping an eye on the cat.

Related Posts

• I Caught John Mercer Staring at Pandora’s Poetry Again
• I’m Starting to Think Something Happened Last Night
• I Think John Mercer Saw Something He Shouldn’t Have

I noticed Karen’s car before I even made it through the front doors at work. That probably doesn’t sound important, and under normal circumstances it wouldn’t be, except Karen’s car wasn’t parked where she normally parks it. It was sitting several rows over, backed into a space near the far end of the lot like someone who either wanted a quick getaway or didn’t want anyone noticing they were there. I stopped walking. There are moments in life when your instincts tell you something is wrong, and apparently mine had decided that a coworker choosing a different parking space qualified as one of them.

I stood there for a few seconds staring at the car. Same make. Same color. Same little thing hanging from the rearview mirror. Definitely Karen’s. The sensible explanation was that somebody had taken her usual spot. Unfortunately, my brain had already rejected the sensible explanation due to insufficient intrigue. Why would Karen park all the way over there? More importantly, why would she back in? Karen normally pulled straight into parking spaces like a person with nothing to hide. Backing in suggested preparation. Planning. Possibly escape.

By the time I reached my desk, I’d developed three theories, two of which involved Dave. This was mostly because Dave was already at work, sitting at his computer with a cup of coffee and behaving exactly like someone who knew why Karen had parked differently. Admittedly, that behavior consisted primarily of typing. Still, he was typing with suspicious confidence. I casually asked whether Karen was in yet. Dave glanced toward her desk and said, “Yeah, I think she got here early.” Then he went back to his computer.

Early.

There it was.

I sat down and pretended to check my email while considering the implications. Karen had arrived early, parked in an unusual location, and Dave knew about it. Maybe not everything about it, but enough to answer without hesitation. I looked toward Karen’s desk. She wasn’t there. Her bag was sitting beside her chair, though, which meant she was somewhere in the building. A normal person might conclude that she had gone to get coffee, use the restroom, or talk to somebody. I concluded that she had abandoned her command post temporarily.

My phone buzzed. It was Pandora asking whether I’d remembered to pick up cat food after work. Apparently Mr Whiskers had spent the morning sitting beside his nearly empty food container staring at her like she had personally caused a nationwide kibble shortage. I told her I remembered. Then I stared at the message for a moment because something about Mr Whiskers suddenly seemed relevant.

Last night, Mr Whiskers had been sitting in the window.

The parking lot was visible from our apartment.

Karen’s car had obviously traveled through a parking lot this morning.

I stopped myself there because even by my standards that connection needed work.

Karen appeared a few minutes later carrying coffee and a folder. She smiled when she saw me. “Morning.”

“Morning,” I said, watching carefully.

She walked to her desk.

Nothing else happened.

Which was suspicious.

People hiding things frequently try to appear normal, and Karen was currently putting on an absolutely masterful performance. She set down her coffee, opened the folder, logged into her computer, and started working. Not one nervous glance toward the parking lot. Not one whispered phone call. Not even an unnecessary adjustment of the blinds.

I waited about ten minutes before asking the obvious question.

“You parked somewhere different today.”

Karen looked at me.

Dave looked at me.

I immediately realized I had somehow made this sound much stranger than it had sounded inside my head.

“Did I?” Karen asked.

“You’re over by the far row.”

She shrugged. “Someone was in my usual spot.”

That was exactly the kind of explanation I had predicted she would use.

I nodded slowly. “And you backed in.”

Dave stopped typing.

Karen stared at me for another second. “Yes, Hal. I backed into a parking space.”

There was a silence.

Dave took a drink of coffee.

I could practically hear him trying not to become involved.

I turned back toward my monitor, but the explanation bothered me. Someone had taken Karen’s normal space. Fine. But who? And why today? Parking spaces weren’t assigned, technically, but people developed habits. Karen parked in roughly the same place every morning. Everybody knew it. Well, apparently I knew it, which was concerning enough on its own.

I glanced at Dave.

“What?” he said.

“Nothing.”

“You’re staring at me.”

“I’m thinking.”

“That’s what worries me.”

There was something in his tone. Not fear exactly. More like the exhausted resignation of a man who had watched me turn ordinary workplace events into criminal investigations before. I decided not to press him. If Dave was involved, applying pressure this early would only make him more careful.

Around lunchtime I walked past the window overlooking the parking lot and checked Karen’s car again. Still there. Nothing unusual around it. No mysterious packages. No strangers. No clandestine handoffs. Just a perfectly ordinary car sitting in a perfectly ordinary parking space.

That should have reassured me.

Instead, it made the whole thing worse.

If something actually was going on, whoever was behind it was extremely good.

I started thinking about Karen’s behavior over the past few days. She’d been arriving a little earlier. She and Dave had spoken quietly near his desk yesterday. She’d carried a folder into a meeting room that morning. Individually, these things meant nothing. Together, they also meant nothing, but they meant nothing in a pattern, and patterns are where things get dangerous.

Then Pandora texted me a picture of Mr Whiskers sitting beside his food bowl.

He looked furious.

I zoomed in.

There was absolutely no reason to zoom in.

For one ridiculous second I wondered whether Mr Whiskers had seen something from the apartment window that morning. Then I remembered that our cat had no idea where Karen worked, what she drove, or why any of this mattered. He wanted food. That was the entire scope of his investigation.

I put my phone down.

Maybe I was getting carried away.

Then I saw Karen and Dave talking again.

They were standing near the printer, and Karen handed Dave a piece of paper. Dave looked at it, nodded, and handed it back. Karen said something. Dave laughed.

I knew it.

I didn’t know what I knew, exactly, but I knew it.

I waited until Karen walked away before approaching Dave.

“What did she give you?”

Dave looked at me. “Who?”

“Karen.”

“A printout.”

“Of what?”

He stared at me for a long moment. “Hal, are you investigating Karen?”

“No.”

“You asked me what time she arrived.”

“Conversation.”

“You asked her why she backed into a parking space.”

“Observation.”

“And now you want to know what she printed.”

“Professional curiosity.”

Dave leaned back in his chair. “It was a spreadsheet.”

Of course it was a spreadsheet. That was almost too perfect. Spreadsheets contained data. Data contained information. Information could contain practically anything.

“What kind of spreadsheet?”

Dave narrowed his eyes. “I’m not telling you now.”

That changed everything.

By midafternoon I had constructed an increasingly elaborate theory involving Karen’s early arrival, the displaced parking space, Dave, the mysterious spreadsheet, and the possibility that someone in the office was coordinating something nobody wanted me to know about. I still hadn’t figured out what the conspiracy was actually supposed to accomplish, but I considered that a minor detail. Motive could come later.

Then Karen stopped at my desk.

“You know why I backed into the space?”

I looked up.

She pointed toward the parking lot.

“There was a delivery truck behind me when I pulled in. I had to move around it, and backing into that space was easier.”

I said nothing.

“And the spreadsheet Dave saw was the project tracker.”

I continued saying nothing.

“And I came in early because I have an appointment this afternoon.”

She folded her arms.

“Anything else you’d like to investigate?”

I considered my options.

“No.”

Karen nodded. “Good.”

She walked away.

Dave was laughing before she even reached her desk.

That evening, I told Pandora the whole story while she stood in the kitchen putting groceries away. She listened patiently through the unusual parking space, the early arrival, the conversation with Dave, the spreadsheet, and my brief consideration of Mr Whiskers as a potential witness.

When I finished, Pandora stared at me.

“So Karen parked somewhere else.”

“Yes.”

“Because there was a delivery truck.”

“Apparently.”

“And Dave looked at a spreadsheet.”

“Yes.”

“Because you work together.”

“That is one interpretation.”

Pandora slowly closed the refrigerator.

Mr Whiskers was sitting on the kitchen floor between us, looking up at me.

Pandora glanced down at him.

“Don’t encourage him.”

Mr Whiskers blinked.

I pointed at him. “See? He knows something.”

Pandora picked up the bag of cat food and walked away.

I watched Mr Whiskers follow her.

And that’s when it hit me.

Karen’s car probably wasn’t hiding anything.

But Mr Whiskers?

I’m keeping an eye on him.

Related Posts

• I Think John Mercer Might Be Controlling Karen
• I Think Pandora Left Her Phone Out for a Reason
• The Milk Run That Turned Into a Conspiracy

I was sitting on the couch staring at Mr Whiskers, who had been asleep on my lap long enough for both of my legs to lose circulation. His orange fur looked particularly disheveled today, which probably meant he’d been rolling around somewhere he shouldn’t have been. There were several reasonable explanations for this. Mr Whiskers is a cat, after all. Looking slightly disreputable is practically part of the job. Still, I found myself inspecting him like a detective examining evidence. Maybe he’d gotten into something. Maybe Pandora had brushed him earlier and somehow made things worse. Maybe it was just normal shedding. The rational part of my brain suggested I stop investigating the cat’s grooming habits and enjoy the fact that he was asleep. Unfortunately, the rational part of my brain has never had much authority around here.

That’s when I noticed Pandora’s phone sitting on the coffee table, still connected to the charger. The screen lit up every few seconds with notifications. None of them looked urgent from where I was sitting, and obviously I wasn’t going to start reading her messages, but their mere existence was apparently enough to activate whatever defective surveillance equipment lives inside my head. Who was messaging her this much? Work? Friends? Some group chat I’d forgotten about? Then my brain supplied another possibility: John Mercer. I immediately looked across the room at John, who was sitting on the other end of the couch staring at his own phone. That proved absolutely nothing, which naturally made it seem extremely suspicious.

John lives here, so there was nothing unusual about him sitting in our living room. There was also nothing unusual about him checking his phone. Yet suddenly I was wondering whether he and Pandora had been texting each other about something. They’re friends. Of course they text. Normal people would have reached that conclusion and moved on with their day. I instead started wondering whether Karen knew anything about it, which made even less sense because Karen lives across the hall and has no responsibility whatsoever to brief me on Pandora’s communications. Somehow, within about thirty seconds, I had transformed two people owning phones into the beginnings of an organized conspiracy.

Then Pandora walked into the room, picked up her phone, looked at the notifications and smiled.

That smile bothered me.

Not because there was anything objectively suspicious about it. It was just a smile. I’ve seen Pandora smile thousands of times. But this particular smile suddenly seemed to contain information I didn’t possess, which is apparently all my brain requires before opening an investigation. “Anything interesting?” I asked, attempting the sort of casual tone normally used by people who are absolutely not interrogating their girlfriends. Pandora glanced at me. “Just some messages.” Then she walked into the kitchen to get a glass of water.

Just some messages.

That was exactly the sort of thing someone with just some messages would say. It was also exactly the sort of thing someone hiding an enormous secret would say. This was going to be difficult.

I looked at John again. He was still staring at his phone. “What?” he asked without looking up. Apparently I had been staring at him long enough for him to notice. “Nothing,” I said. John finally looked at me, studied my face for about two seconds, and returned to his phone. Somehow that made things worse. Either he genuinely didn’t know anything, or John Mercer had developed an astonishing ability to withstand interrogation despite the fact that no interrogation had actually occurred.

Mr Whiskers woke up, stretched across my legs and looked toward the kitchen. His ears rotated slightly when Pandora opened a cabinet. I watched him carefully. Cats supposedly have excellent hearing. Perhaps he had noticed something I hadn’t. Maybe he’d heard conversations between Pandora and John while I was gone. Maybe the notifications meant something to him. Then Mr Whiskers jumped off my lap and walked toward the kitchen.

Interesting.

He was following Pandora.

Of course, Pandora was standing next to the cabinet where we keep the cat treats, but I wasn’t going to let an obvious explanation interfere with a promising lead.

My thoughts drifted to Mrs Jenkins next door. She’d mentioned recently that Pandora seemed unusually busy. At the time, I’d assumed she meant work, because Pandora had been juggling several things lately. But Mrs Jenkins has a remarkable ability to notice details about everyone in the building, including details nobody has asked her to notice. If Pandora really were hiding something, there was an excellent chance Mrs Jenkins had already observed it, categorized it and developed at least three theories about it.

Then I remembered Karen mentioning that Pandora had seemed preoccupied lately. That was two people who had noticed something. Technically one of them was Mrs Jenkins, which probably should count as half a witness because she notices everything, but still. There was a pattern forming.

Pandora returned from the kitchen carrying her water. Mr Whiskers followed directly behind her.

There it was again.

I watched them cross the room together. Pandora sat beside me. Mr Whiskers jumped onto the couch and settled between us as though deliberately establishing a buffer zone. Pandora looked at me. “Why are you staring at the cat?”

“I’m not.”

“You absolutely are.”

I looked away.

That exchange should have ended the investigation. Instead, I started thinking about how attentive Pandora had been lately. She’d asked about my schedule several times. She’d wanted to know when I’d be home. She’d asked whether I had plans for the weekend. At the time, I had interpreted all of this as normal relationship behavior. Now, however, I was beginning to wonder whether she had been collecting information.

Why did she need my schedule?

Why did she care when I’d be home?

Why had she asked what I was doing Saturday afternoon?

There were plenty of innocent explanations, including the extremely obvious possibility that my girlfriend wanted to spend time with me, but that seemed almost too convenient.

I glanced toward John again. He caught me looking this time. “Seriously,” he said, “what are you doing?”

“Thinking.”

“That’s usually when the problems start.”

I ignored him because this investigation was beginning to produce results.

A few days earlier, Pandora and John had spent nearly twenty minutes talking in the kitchen. I hadn’t paid attention at the time because adults are occasionally allowed to communicate without submitting transcripts to me. But now the conversation seemed potentially significant. What had they discussed? Why the kitchen? Why twenty minutes? Why hadn’t either of them briefed me afterward?

Then I remembered something even more troubling: Karen had stopped by later that same evening.

Three people.

Pandora. John. Karen.

I could practically see the lines connecting them.

Mr Whiskers sneezed.

Four.

I immediately realized how ridiculous that was and mentally removed the cat from the organizational chart.

Then another thought occurred to me. What if Pandora wasn’t hiding something from me? What if she was hiding something for me?

That changed everything.

Maybe the questions about my schedule weren’t surveillance. Maybe they were planning. Maybe the conversations with John and Karen weren’t secret meetings. Maybe Pandora was organizing something and needed their help. A surprise? A dinner? Some elaborate plan that required knowing exactly where I would be?

Suddenly all the evidence fit.

Unfortunately, it fit almost too well.

I looked at Pandora. She was scrolling through her phone again with the faintest smile on her face. John was pretending not to pay attention to me. Mr Whiskers was sitting between us washing one paw with the serene confidence of an animal who had absolutely no concerns about household espionage.

I narrowed my eyes.

Pandora noticed.

“What now?” she asked.

“Nothing.”

She stared at me for a moment.

Then she looked at John.

John looked at Pandora.

They both smiled.

There.

That was a signal.

I knew it.

Or they were laughing at me.

Actually, now that I thought about it, that was considerably more likely.

Still, I wasn’t closing the investigation yet. Pandora was definitely hiding something. I just had absolutely no evidence of what it was, why she was hiding it, whether John or Karen had anything to do with it, or whether Mr Whiskers had somehow become involved.

Mr Whiskers looked up at me.

I looked back at him.

He slowly blinked.

Great.

Now the cat was sending signals too.

Related Posts

• I Think My Cat Knows Something I Don’t About Last Night
• I Think the Cat is Trying to Warn Me
• I Knew Something Was Off When Mr. Whiskers Slept In

I’m sitting on the couch, trying to focus on my notes for that marketing project I’ve been putting off, but my mind keeps drifting back to something Pandora said earlier about John Mercer leaving his dirty socks on the floor again. I thought she was joking at first. It sounded like the sort of ordinary complaint anyone might make after nearly tripping over a pair of socks that had somehow migrated from John’s bedroom into the hallway. But there was something about the way she said it. Her tone seemed a little tense. Or deliberate. No, no. Don’t jump to conclusions, Hal. She was talking about socks. People complain about socks every day without secretly communicating anything. Probably.

The problem is that Pandora looked directly at me when she said it. Not at John. Not at the socks. At me. She said, “John really needs to stop leaving things where people can find them,” and then gave me this tiny smile before walking into the kitchen. At the time, I barely noticed. Now I can’t stop thinking about it. Leaving things where people can find them. That’s an oddly specific way of complaining about dirty laundry. Why not just say, “John needs to pick up his socks”? Unless the socks weren’t the point. Unless Pandora was trying to tell me something without John realizing she was telling me something.

I stare at my laptop and attempt to return to work. Three sentences into my notes, I’m thinking about the socks again. John is sitting in the chair across from me, completely absorbed in his phone and apparently unaware that his laundry has become the centerpiece of an emerging intelligence operation. Mr Whiskers is stretched across the back of the couch, watching all of us with the detached expression of someone who already knows how this ends and isn’t impressed.

Pandora comes back from the kitchen carrying a cup of coffee and sits beside me. I wait for her to say something. She doesn’t. She takes a sip and starts scrolling through her phone. Fine. Perfectly normal. Then she glances at me. Just once. I glance back. She looks at her phone again. There it is. A signal. I’m almost certain of it.

Of course, I immediately realize that I have absolutely no idea what the signal means. Maybe she wants me to ask about John’s socks. Maybe she wants me not to ask about John’s socks. Maybe the socks are symbolic. Maybe there aren’t even any socks. I look toward the hallway to verify their existence and, unfortunately, there they are: one gray sock near John’s door and another several feet away beside the wall. So at least the socks are real. That’s comforting. I’m not sure why.

John looks up from his phone. “Why are you staring at my socks?”

“I’m not.”

“You’re staring directly at them.”

“I was looking at the hallway.”

“The hallway containing my socks?”

This is exactly the sort of defensive response I would expect from someone who doesn’t know he’s accidentally involved in whatever Pandora is trying to tell me. I decide not to pursue it. Pandora suppresses a smile. There. Again. She definitely knows something.

I start replaying the morning in my head. Pandora asked what time I was planning to work on my project. She asked whether I had anything scheduled later. Then she mentioned John’s socks. Individually, these things mean nothing. Together, however, they form what I’m beginning to regard as a fairly sophisticated communication sequence. First establish my schedule. Then determine whether I’ll be home. Then introduce an apparently meaningless object into the conversation. Finally, make eye contact. I’m not saying Pandora is sending me a coded message. I’m saying there’s mounting evidence that Pandora is sending me a coded message.

Mr Whiskers suddenly jumps down from the couch and trots into the hallway. He stops beside John’s abandoned sock and sniffs it. Interesting.

John looks over. “Don’t let him take that.”

Pandora laughs. Even more interesting.

Mr Whiskers grabs the sock in his mouth and starts walking toward me. I freeze. John groans. “Seriously?” Pandora is laughing harder now, but I barely hear her because Mr Whiskers has just delivered the object at the center of this entire mystery directly to my feet. He drops it, looks up at me, and sits down. That cannot be random. Cats do not retrieve socks and deliver them to specific people for no reason. Well, maybe they do, but that explanation isn’t particularly useful right now.

I look at Pandora. She looks at me. Then she looks down at the sock. There. That was absolutely a signal.

“What?” I ask.

“What?” Pandora says.

“You looked at the sock.”

“So did you.”

“After you looked at it.”

Pandora stares at me for several seconds. “Hal, Mr Whiskers brought you John’s dirty sock.”

“I know what happened.”

“I’m not sure you do.”

John gets up, retrieves the sock from the floor, and disappears toward his room while muttering something about needing better roommates. Mr Whiskers follows him, presumably because his role in the operation isn’t finished yet.

I try to return to my project, but now I’m thinking about something Pandora said yesterday. She asked whether I’d talked to Dave at work about the proposal I’d been working on. At the time, I assumed she was making conversation. Dave is my coworker, so asking about him isn’t unusual. But what if that was part of the signal too? Maybe Pandora knows I’ve been obsessing over the project and is trying to tell me something about it without coming right out and saying it. Maybe she thinks I’m overlooking something obvious. Maybe “stop leaving things where people can find them” wasn’t about John at all. Maybe she saw the project notes I left sitting on the coffee table.

I look at the table. My notes are still there. One page is slightly crooked. I straighten it. Pandora watches me.

“Did you read these?” I ask.

“Some of them.”

My heart skips a beat. “Why?”

“They were sitting on the coffee table.”

Exactly. Leaving things where people can find them. I knew it.

“What did you think?”

Pandora shrugs. “I think you’re overcomplicating it.”

For a moment, everything becomes perfectly clear. The socks. The notes. The glances. The questions about my schedule. Pandora has been trying to tell me that I’m overthinking the project. She knew if she said it directly, I’d probably argue with her, so instead she constructed an elaborate series of subtle clues designed to lead me toward the conclusion myself. That is actually brilliant.

“You could have just told me,” I say.

Pandora lowers her phone. “I just did.”

“No, before that.”

“I told you yesterday.”

I pause. “You said I was overthinking the proposal?”

“Twice.”

That complicates the theory considerably.

From the hallway, John calls out, “Has anyone seen my other sock?” Pandora looks at me. I look at Pandora. Neither of us says anything. Then Mr Whiskers trots into the living room carrying the missing sock. Pandora bursts out laughing.

I don’t.

Because now I’m wondering whether that was the real signal. And judging by the way Mr Whiskers is looking at me, I’m pretty sure he knows I finally got it.

Related Posts

• I Think Pandora’s Hiding Something in the Wash
• I Just Caught Pandora Glancing at the Shed Twice
• I Knew Something Was Off When Pandora Left Her Laptop Open

I’m sitting on the couch trying to focus on my laptop when Mrs. Jenkins’ voice comes booming through the wall from next door. I can’t make out every word, but she’s clearly having some kind of disagreement with her husband, and judging by the volume, Mr. Jenkins has either committed a serious offense or loaded the dishwasher incorrectly. John Mercer is sitting at the other end of the room staring at his phone, apparently capable of ignoring sounds that would interfere with commercial aircraft, while Mr. Whiskers is curled beside me, equally unconcerned. Then Pandora walks into the room, and suddenly Mrs. Jenkins isn’t the thing distracting me anymore. Pandora’s hair is pulled into a ponytail. That’s it. That’s the entire observation. Except it’s not her usual ponytail. It’s higher than normal, pulled tight at the sides, with a few strands deliberately arranged around the back of her neck. I’ve seen Pandora wear her hair up plenty of times, but something about this looks different. Intentional. Strategic. She catches me staring and raises an eyebrow. “What?” she asks. I immediately look back at my laptop and tell her nothing.

This is where a reasonable person would stop thinking about it. Unfortunately, I have never claimed to be that person. I try reading the sentence on my screen again, but my eyes keep drifting toward Pandora. Yesterday at the grocery store, her hair was down. Last night, it was down. This morning, suddenly, ponytail. People change hairstyles. Obviously. There are probably millions of ponytails happening around the world right now without anyone launching an investigation. Still, I can’t shake the feeling that this particular ponytail is performing a function beyond keeping hair out of Pandora’s face. Maybe she’s hiding something. I don’t know what someone could conceivably hide behind a ponytail, which admittedly weakens the theory considerably.

Mr. Whiskers climbs onto my lap and starts kneading my leg while I pretend to work. Pandora sits across from me and starts scrolling through her phone. I casually glance at the back of her neck whenever she looks away. Nothing obvious. No bandage. No mysterious tattoo. No evidence of clandestine surgery. Just hair. Then she reaches up and adjusts the ponytail. Interesting. Nobody adjusts something unless something needs adjusting. I realize immediately how stupid that sounds, but the thought has already entered the investigation. John looks up from his phone and asks why I keep staring at Pandora. I tell him I don’t. “You absolutely do,” he says. Pandora looks over, and I become extremely interested in my laptop. “I’m working,” I tell them. John stares at me for another second before returning to his phone. He knows. I don’t know what he knows, but the fact that he noticed me noticing Pandora means there is now another witness. This has officially become more complicated.

I start reconstructing yesterday. Pandora seemed normal at the grocery store. We argued briefly over whether we needed another bottle of olive oil, which I maintain was a reasonable purchase because you can never know exactly how much olive oil remains by looking at the bottle from the outside. Afterward, everything seemed fine. She didn’t disappear mysteriously. She didn’t receive any suspicious calls. She didn’t suddenly announce that she needed to “take care of something.” Nothing happened that would explain why she woke up today apparently needing a hairstyle capable of concealing evidence. Unless something happened this morning. I glance at her again. She catches me. “What?” she asks. “Nothing,” I say. “Hal.” I hesitate before admitting that I’m just looking at her hair. Pandora touches the ponytail and asks, “My hair?” There it is. She touched it immediately. Defensive gesture. Or possibly the normal human response when someone unexpectedly announces that he’s staring at your hair.

I ask whether she did something different with it. Pandora looks at me like the answer should be obvious and says, “I put it in a ponytail.” I tell her I can see that. “Congratulations,” she replies, and John laughs from the other end of the couch. Pandora goes back to her phone, but now I’m more suspicious because she answered too quickly. There was no hesitation whatsoever, almost as though she’d prepared the answer in advance. I decide not to pursue it because good investigators know when to back off. I manage to follow that principle for approximately forty-five seconds before asking, “What happened to your neck?” Pandora slowly lowers her phone. John stops scrolling. Even Mr. Whiskers looks up. “My neck?” she asks. I explain that I didn’t say something happened; I’m merely asking whether something happened. Pandora points out that those are basically the same question. I disagree. They are completely different questions.

Pandora gives me the look she uses when she’s deciding whether explaining something to me will make the situation better or somehow much worse. I’ve seen this look before. It usually means my theory is about to encounter reality. She finally turns around and lifts her ponytail, revealing a tiny red mark near the back of her neck. I knew it. For one glorious second, every irrational thought I’ve had over the last twenty minutes assembles itself into a magnificent tower of vindication. Then Pandora says, “Mosquito.” I stare at the mark and ask whether she means a mosquito bite. She tells me she got bitten while we were carrying groceries inside yesterday. John starts laughing, which I ignore because there is still one unresolved question. If the mark came from a mosquito, why the ponytail? Pandora turns around and stares at me. “Because it’s hot.”

That’s her explanation. It’s August. She’s hot. So she put her hair up. I sit there processing this disappointingly sensible chain of events while John continues enjoying himself far more than the situation warrants. Mr. Whiskers settles back onto my lap, apparently satisfied that the investigation has concluded. Pandora studies me for a moment before asking what exactly I thought she was hiding. That is an excellent question, and it occurs to me that I never actually got that far. “I hadn’t established that yet,” I tell her. Pandora stares at me. “So you thought I was hiding something, but you didn’t know what?” I explain that this is generally why people investigate things. John laughs even harder.

Pandora shakes her head and walks toward the kitchen. As she passes behind the couch, she flicks me lightly with the end of her ponytail. I watch her disappear around the corner and reconsider the evidence. Mosquito bite. Heat. Ponytail. Completely reasonable. Case closed. Probably. Then I notice John smiling at his phone, and suddenly I’m wondering what the hell that’s about.

Related Posts

• I Think Karen Is Involved in This Somehow
• I Think John Mercer Is in on It Too
• I Think Pandora’s Building Some Kind of Social Intelligence Network

I had just poured myself a cup of coffee when something small caught my attention. Pandora’s favorite mug was sitting on the kitchen counter, still warm, but she wasn’t anywhere in the apartment. We’d talked about having breakfast together before she headed to class, so seeing the mug without seeing her felt… odd. Not alarming. Just odd. She could have stepped outside to take a phone call or run down to her car for something. There were dozens of perfectly reasonable explanations. Unfortunately, my brain has never been particularly interested in perfectly reasonable explanations.

John Mercer was already awake, which wasn’t unusual, but the apartment was strangely quiet. Normally I’d hear the television, a video game, or the steady tapping of his keyboard long before I wandered into the kitchen. Today there was almost nothing. Every so often I’d hear a floorboard creak or a cabinet close, but otherwise it was silent enough that I could hear Mr. Whiskers meowing at a bird outside the window. The silence itself wasn’t suspicious, but the fact that I noticed it immediately made me wonder why.

I carried my coffee into the living room and found John reading a textbook with his headphones around his neck instead of over his ears. He looked up, nodded, and went right back to studying. That was it. No conversation. No unnecessary commentary. Just quiet. It struck me as unusual because John usually had something playing in the background while he worked. Today it was almost as if he was making an effort not to disturb anyone. I caught myself wondering whether he’d seen Pandora leave and was deliberately avoiding mentioning it. Then I reminded myself that people are allowed to read quietly without participating in a mystery.

Mr. Whiskers padded into the room, glanced at John, then looked toward the front door before returning to the windowsill. Naturally, my imagination interpreted this as the cat silently confirming that something important had happened. In reality, he was probably hoping someone would open the door so he could inspect the hallway for the third time that morning. Cats are many things, but reliable witnesses aren’t usually among them.

My phone buzzed with a text from Karen asking if I still wanted to meet for coffee later in the week. I smiled, sent back a quick reply, and immediately managed to connect that completely unrelated message to Pandora’s missing breakfast. What if Pandora had left early to meet Karen? What if John knew about it? What if he thought Pandora had already told me and didn’t want to accidentally spoil the surprise? Within thirty seconds I’d built an entire theory around a coffee mug, a quiet roommate, and a perfectly ordinary text message.

The more I thought about it, the more ridiculous my own reasoning became. Pandora had every reason to leave the apartment for a few minutes without filing a detailed itinerary. John had every reason to enjoy a quiet morning before class. Karen had every reason to invite me out for coffee without secretly coordinating everyone’s schedules. The only person turning these unrelated events into a detective novel was me.

Just then the front door opened and Pandora stepped inside carrying a small paper bag from the neighborhood bakery. “Sorry,” she said with a smile. “The line was longer than I expected. I figured I’d surprise everyone with fresh cinnamon rolls.” She set the bag on the counter and laughed when she saw me staring at her mug. “I forgot to rinse it before I left.”

John looked up from his book, smiled, and closed it. “That’s what you’ve been worried about?” he asked. I admitted that I may have briefly suspected he’d witnessed something mysterious and was keeping it from me. He blinked once before replying, “Hal… I was trying to study quietly because I thought you were still asleep.”

I stood there for a moment holding my coffee while Pandora unpacked pastries, John returned to his book, and Mr. Whiskers immediately abandoned all interest in imaginary conspiracies in favor of investigating the bakery bag. Watching him sniff enthusiastically at the cinnamon rolls, I realized I’d once again mistaken an ordinary morning for the opening chapter of a mystery novel. John Mercer hadn’t seen something he shouldn’t have. The only thing he’d seen was me turning breakfast into an international investigation.

Related Posts

• I Think Pandora’s Humming is Mind Control
• I Caught John Mercer Staring at Pandora’s Poetry Again
• I’m Positive She Didn’t Turn Off Location Services

I was sitting on the couch when I noticed Pandora standing in the laundry room with an expression that suggested she was negotiating with the laws of chemistry. She held one of John Mercer’s favorite T-shirts up to the light, frowned, sprayed something on a stubborn stain, rubbed the fabric together, and then held it up again for another inspection. Mr. Whiskers had claimed the windowsill nearby and was watching the entire process with the intense concentration of a quality-control inspector. Meanwhile, I remembered I should probably take the trash out before Mrs. Jenkins wandered past our apartment and made another comment about “mystery aromas” drifting through the hallway. It was shaping up to be a perfectly ordinary afternoon, which, in my experience, usually meant my imagination was about to make it considerably less ordinary.

Pandora sighed quietly as she worked on the stain. “How does he never notice these until they’ve gone through the dryer?” she muttered to herself. That was the first thing that caught my attention. She wasn’t annoyed because she was doing laundry. She was annoyed because dried stains are much harder to remove than fresh ones. John had a remarkable talent for treating every shirt like it was indestructible, and Pandora, being far more patient than I would have been, usually managed to rescue them anyway. Still, there was something about the determination on her face that made me wonder if there was more going on than simple laundry.

Naturally, my brain skipped right over the obvious explanation. What if the stain itself wasn’t the problem? What if Pandora was trying unusually hard to remove it because there was something important about that shirt? She kept examining the fabric under the light, scrubbing a little more, then checking it again. To a reasonable person, that looked exactly like someone trying to save a favorite shirt. To me, however, it looked suspiciously like someone making absolutely certain no evidence remained. I had no idea what the evidence might be, but once my imagination opened that particular door, it refused to close it again.

Mr. Whiskers didn’t help matters. He never took his eyes off Pandora the entire time. Every now and then his tail twitched, as though he were silently commenting on the investigation unfolding before him. I caught myself wondering if he had witnessed whatever mysterious event had created the stain in the first place. Then I remembered I was trying to interpret the body language of a cat whose greatest achievement that morning had been knocking a sock behind the washing machine. Even by my standards, that felt like a stretch.

Just then my phone buzzed with another message from Karen asking if I still wanted to grab coffee later in the week. I started typing a reply but stopped halfway through because Pandora had picked up the shirt again. Was she smiling? No… she was just relieved the stain was finally coming out. I looked back at my phone, then at Pandora, then back at the shirt. Somewhere in the middle of that sequence, I briefly convinced myself the timing of Karen’s text couldn’t possibly be a coincidence. Fortunately, common sense returned before I embarrassed myself by trying to connect coffee invitations to laundry detergent.

A few minutes later John wandered into the room, glanced at the shirt, and smiled. “You got the barbecue sauce out?” he asked. Pandora nodded without even looking up. “Mostly. Next time try wearing a napkin.” John laughed, thanked her, grabbed a bottle of water, and disappeared back down the hallway without giving the shirt another thought. I stared after him. Barbecue sauce? That was it? I’d been constructing an elaborate theory involving hidden motives and mysterious evidence, and the villain of the story turned out to be ribs.

Pandora carried the clean shirt into the living room and folded it neatly before placing it on John’s stack of laundry. She noticed me watching and raised an eyebrow. “What?” she asked. I hesitated for a second before deciding honesty was probably my safest option. “For a little while,” I admitted, “I thought you were hiding something.” She looked down at the perfectly folded shirt, then back at me with an amused smile. “Hal,” she said, “the only thing I’m hiding is John’s inability to eat barbecue without wearing half of it.”

I couldn’t help laughing. The entire mystery collapsed in an instant, leaving nothing behind except one clean T-shirt and another reminder that my imagination rarely needs much encouragement. Mr. Whiskers stretched lazily on the windowsill, yawned, and closed his eyes as though he’d known the answer from the beginning. Watching him settle in for another nap, I realized I’d once again spent far more energy solving an imaginary conspiracy than it would’ve taken to simply ask a perfectly reasonable question. Sometimes the biggest mystery in the apartment isn’t what Pandora is doing. It’s why my brain insists every ordinary afternoon is the opening chapter of a detective novel.

Related Posts

• The Cat’s Behavior Is More Suspicious Than I Thought
• I’m Starting to Suspect Mr Whiskers Knows More
• I Think She’s Leaving Clues for Mrs Jenkins

Dave sent me one of the most dangerous text messages in the English language. Need to talk tomorrow. That was it. Four words. No explanation, no context, and not even an emoji to reassure me that everything was fine. I was sitting on the couch when my phone buzzed, Pandora was reading on her tablet beside me, Mr. Whiskers was asleep across my lap, and down the hall I could hear John Mercer typing away on his laptop. It had been a perfectly peaceful evening until those four words landed on my screen. I read them again, hoping there was some hidden meaning I’d missed the first time. There wasn’t. Somehow that made it worse.

Dave and I worked together, so there were plenty of ordinary reasons he might want to talk. Maybe he had a question about a project. Maybe he’d discovered an error in one of our reports. Maybe he wanted to ask if I was available for something later in the week. Unfortunately, my imagination dismissed every sensible explanation almost immediately. Instead, it promoted those four harmless words into the beginning of a full-blown workplace catastrophe. I found myself rereading the text over and over, convinced there had to be something between the lines that I simply hadn’t deciphered yet. The longer I stared at it, the more certain I became that tomorrow’s conversation would somehow change everything, even though I couldn’t explain how or why.

Pandora eventually looked up from her tablet and smiled. “You’ve read that text at least six times.” I corrected her automatically. “Seven.” She held out her hand, and I passed her my phone. After reading the message she simply handed it back without the slightest hint of concern. “Looks like Dave wants to talk tomorrow.” “That’s exactly what worries me,” I replied. She laughed. “Hal, if it were actually bad news, he probably wouldn’t wait until tomorrow. And if he wanted you to panic, he would’ve written something like, ‘We really need to talk.’” I considered that for a moment before nodding. “You’re right. That somehow sounds much worse.” She smiled, returned to her book, and apparently considered the mystery solved. Unfortunately, my brain had only just begun writing theories.

John wandered out of his room carrying an empty coffee mug and found me staring blankly at my phone. After I explained the text, he waited patiently for the rest of the story. When I admitted there wasn’t any more, he blinked once and said, “Sounds like tomorrow’s conversation.” I admired how effortlessly he reached sensible conclusions. Mine preferred wandering through unnecessary speculation first. Just then my phone buzzed again with a weather alert, and Mr. Whiskers immediately reached out with one lazy paw and tapped the vibrating screen before settling back down for another nap. I pointed at the cat. “See? Even he thinks it’s important.” John looked at Mr. Whiskers, then at me, and smiled. “No, Hal. He thinks your phone moved.”

The rest of the evening became an exercise in creative overthinking. I convinced myself Dave might be about to tell me I’d been volunteered for a project, that the office was being reorganized, that he’d accidentally created a disaster and needed my help, or that someone upstairs had made a decision that would affect everyone. Every theory seemed convincing for about thirty seconds before another one replaced it. Pandora watched the entire process with quiet amusement before finally asking, “Have you considered waiting until tomorrow?” I sighed. “That feels like giving up.” She shook her head. “No. That’s called patience.” I wasn’t entirely convinced the two were the same thing.

By the time I arrived at work the following morning, I had mentally prepared myself for almost every possible disaster. Dave spotted me almost immediately and waved me into his office. I took a deep breath, walked in, and waited for the bad news. Instead, he reached into a folder, pulled out a flyer, and slid it across the desk. “The food trucks are coming Friday,” he said. “I wanted to see if you wanted to grab lunch before the lines get ridiculous.” I stared at him for several seconds before asking, “That’s what you wanted to talk about?” Dave looked genuinely confused. “Yeah. Why? Did you think something was wrong?” I couldn’t help laughing. I’d spent nearly twenty-four hours preparing for a workplace crisis, and all he’d wanted was someone to split a barbecue lunch with.

That evening, after I told Pandora the whole story, she smiled exactly the way I knew she would. “So,” she asked, “was Dave a bigger problem than you thought?” I laughed, shaking my head. “Not even close.” She closed her tablet and looked at me expectantly. “Then what was?” I looked down at Mr. Whiskers, who had already reclaimed his spot on the couch and fallen asleep without a single concern in the world. “The biggest problem,” I admitted, “was giving my imagination twenty-four uninterrupted hours to explain a four-word text message.” Mr. Whiskers opened one eye, yawned, and promptly went back to sleep. Somehow he’d known from the very beginning what had taken me an entire day to figure out: sometimes “Need to talk tomorrow” really does just mean “Need to talk tomorrow.”

Related Posts

• I Suspect Mrs Jenkins Has an Unusual Lawnmower
• I Think John Mercer Is Trying to Drown Out My Thoughts
• I’m Positive She Didn’t Turn Off Location Services

I was sitting on the couch watching Mr. Whiskers meticulously groom himself when something started bothering me. It wasn’t anything dramatic. In fact, it was almost disappointingly ordinary. Pandora had come over for dinner the night before, and we’d spent the evening talking about work, our schedules, and the usual little things that fill up an ordinary weekday. She’d helped wash the dishes before heading home, kissed me goodnight, and reminded me not to stay up too late. It had been a perfectly pleasant evening. Yet somehow I woke up with the unmistakable feeling that she’d figured something out about me and simply forgotten to mention it.

John Mercer was in his room watching television, the occasional burst of laughter drifting down the hallway whenever the audience on whatever sitcom he’d chosen erupted into applause. Mr. Whiskers seemed entirely unconcerned with the mysteries occupying my mind, pausing only long enough to inspect one paw before returning to his morning grooming routine with impressive dedication. Across the street, Mrs. Jenkins was watering the flowers outside her house exactly as she did most mornings. Everything around me looked perfectly normal, which somehow made my strange feeling even harder to ignore.

The more I thought about the previous evening, the more convinced I became that I’d missed something. Pandora had smiled a couple of times during our conversation in that thoughtful way she has when she’s piecing together an idea. At the time I’d assumed she was simply listening. Now I wondered whether she’d quietly solved some problem while I was still trying to explain it. She has a habit of connecting dots before I even realize there are dots to connect, and every now and then she’ll casually mention an obvious solution that somehow escaped me entirely. What if she’d done that again, only this time she’d forgotten to tell me?

I tried replaying the conversation in my head. We talked about work. We talked about grocery shopping. We debated whether we were overdue for another weekend road trip. Somewhere in the middle of all that she’d paused for a moment, smiled, and nodded almost to herself. At the time I hadn’t given it another thought. Now I couldn’t stop wondering what she’d been thinking. Had she remembered something important? Had she solved a problem I’d been complaining about for weeks? Or had she simply remembered that we’d forgotten to buy paper towels?

John wandered into the living room carrying a bowl of cereal and immediately noticed me staring blankly into space.

“You’ve got the detective face on again,” he said.

“The detective face?”

“The one where you’ve convinced yourself there’s a mystery but haven’t figured out what it is yet.”

I sighed.

“I think Pandora figured something out last night.”

“What kind of something?”

“I don’t know.”

He waited.

“That’s… remarkably unhelpful.”

“I know.”

John took a bite of cereal and nodded thoughtfully.

“So your theory is that Pandora solved a mystery that you can’t identify, about a subject you don’t remember discussing?”

“When you say it like that, it sounds a little weak.”

“It sounded a little weak before I said it.”

I was about to defend myself when my phone buzzed. It was a text from Pandora.

Found the coupon for that coffee maker you wanted. Saved us forty dollars. Forgot to tell you last night.

I stared at the message for several seconds before laughing.

That was it.

That was the mystery.

She’d uncovered absolutely nothing profound. She hadn’t discovered a hidden truth about our lives, uncovered a secret, or solved some enormous problem. She’d simply found a coupon while browsing online and forgotten to mention it during dinner.

John looked up from his cereal.

“Well?”

“I was right.”

His eyebrows rose.

“She did discover something.”

“What was it?”

“A forty-dollar coupon.”

He blinked once.

“You spent half an hour trying to remember a conversation because of a coupon?”

“I didn’t know it was a coupon.”

Mr. Whiskers chose that exact moment to jump onto the coffee table, knock an advertising flyer onto the floor with one casual swipe of his paw, and walk away as though he’d just contributed something meaningful to the investigation.

John laughed.

“I think the cat solved more mysteries than you did today.”

I looked down at the coupon on my phone and smiled.

Maybe Pandora had uncovered something I should know after all.

It just wasn’t nearly as dramatic as my imagination had insisted it would be.

Related Posts

• The Ordinary Scene in My Living Room Lies
• I Think Mrs Jenkins Is Watching Us Closely Today
• I Knew Something Was Off When Mr. Whiskers Slept In