I noticed the first hair tie on Tuesday morning. It was sitting on the kitchen counter beside the coffee maker, a bright purple thing that looked completely out of place among the usual collection of mugs, unpaid bills, and whatever John Mercer had decided qualified as breakfast that week. Pandora had always used black hair ties, at least as far as I could remember. I couldn’t recall ever seeing her wear a purple one, which made its sudden appearance worth noting. I picked it up, stretched it between my fingers, and put it back exactly where I’d found it. Then I stood there wondering why she’d left it in the kitchen when we had an entire dresser in our bedroom dedicated to storing things we couldn’t find when we needed them. I probably would have forgotten about it if Mr Whiskers hadn’t appeared around the corner, spotted the purple hair tie, and immediately started walking toward it with the determined expression of a cat who had just discovered an unattended chicken dinner.
I moved the hair tie out of his reach before he could get his paws on it. Mr Whiskers stopped, looked at me, and gave a short, irritated meow. I told him he wasn’t allowed to play with it, which was apparently the funniest thing I’d said all morning because he continued staring at me as though I had misunderstood the nature of our relationship. Pandora came into the kitchen a few minutes later, still getting ready for work, and I asked her about the new hair tie. She glanced at it, said she’d bought a pack because her old ones kept disappearing, and went back to looking for her keys. That seemed reasonable enough, although I couldn’t remember seeing any of the old ones disappear. In fact, I couldn’t remember seeing most of them at all. It occurred to me that I had been living with Pandora for years without paying much attention to her hair accessories, which probably explained why I was suddenly treating a purple elastic band like an archaeological discovery.
By Wednesday, there were three of them. One purple, one blue, and another that was somewhere between pink and orange, depending on the lighting. I found the blue one beside the fruit bowl and the pinkish one near the kitchen table, where Pandora sometimes worked on her drawings. I wasn’t particularly concerned about the colors, but the locations bothered me. Pandora was usually pretty good about putting things away, especially anything Mr Whiskers might mistake for a toy. I mentioned this to John Mercer while he was making toast. He looked at the hair ties, looked at me, and asked whether I had considered the possibility that Pandora simply owned more than one. I explained that the number wasn’t the issue. The issue was that they kept appearing in different places, almost as if somebody was moving them around. John took a bite of toast and said, “Hal, that’s generally what happens when people use things.” I could tell immediately that he wasn’t going to be much help.
What bothered me most was that Pandora didn’t seem remotely interested in the situation. When I asked why she kept leaving the hair ties around, she said she didn’t think she was leaving that many out. Then she opened a kitchen drawer, took out another one, and tied her hair back while we were talking. I hadn’t even known we kept hair ties in that drawer. It was the same drawer where we stored batteries, takeout menus, and a screwdriver nobody could remember buying. Apparently, it had also become a secondary hair-accessory department. I asked when that happened, and Pandora gave me the sort of look she usually reserves for questions about why the refrigerator light goes off when you close the door. “Hal, I’ve been keeping them there for months,” she said. That was unsettling information. Not because she had done anything wrong, but because it suggested there were entire organizational systems operating in our home without my knowledge.
Later that afternoon, I found Mr Whiskers sitting beneath the kitchen table, watching something near one of the chair legs. His tail was moving slowly from side to side, and he had that focused expression he gets when a bug makes the mistake of entering his territory. I crouched down to see what had caught his attention and discovered another purple hair tie lying partly beneath the chair. Before I could pick it up, he reached out with one paw and hooked it toward himself. I took it away, reminded him that it wasn’t a toy, and placed it on top of the refrigerator. He followed the entire operation with his eyes. When I turned around, he was still sitting there, staring upward. I had seen that look before. It was the same look he gave the cabinet where we kept his treats, except this time he appeared to be calculating the height of the refrigerator.
I decided to ask Pandora whether she was missing any hair ties. She said she probably was, which didn’t narrow things down much. Apparently, she’d bought the new pack because she could never find one when she needed it, even though she was certain she had plenty. I asked whether she’d considered keeping them all in one place. She reminded me that she had tried that, but they kept disappearing from the little dish on our dresser. I remembered the dish. It was a small ceramic bowl that I had always assumed was decorative, mostly because it contained a collection of objects I had never been encouraged to touch. Pandora explained that she’d been putting her hair ties there for years. I asked how many she thought she’d lost. She shrugged and said, “Enough that I’m considering buying them in bulk.” That was when I began to suspect we weren’t dealing with ordinary forgetfulness.
John found me examining the ceramic dish that evening. I had counted four hair ties, two loose buttons, a paper clip, and something that might once have been part of an earring. He stood in the bedroom doorway for a moment before asking what I was doing. I told him I was trying to establish how many hair ties Pandora actually owned. He wanted to know why. I explained that if we knew how many she started with and how many remained, we might be able to determine whether they were being misplaced or removed. John nodded slowly, the way people do when they’re deciding whether to continue a conversation or pretend they have an urgent appointment. “Have you checked under the furniture?” he asked. I told him that was a reasonable suggestion, although I didn’t appreciate his tone. He said he wasn’t using a tone. Then he walked away laughing, which I felt undermined his claim.
The following morning, I mentioned the situation to Karen while we were getting coffee at work. She listened patiently as I explained the changing colors, the kitchen counter, and the mysterious losses from Pandora’s dresser. When I finished, she asked whether we had a cat. I told her we did, but I didn’t see what that had to do with anything. Karen stared at me for a moment, then asked whether I’d ever watched a cat play with a hair tie. I admitted that Mr Whiskers had shown some interest in them, but I had already taken precautions. Dave happened to walk past just as I was explaining this and wanted to know what precautions were necessary for a hair tie. I told him the details were complicated. He said, “You live with an orange cat, Hal. Nothing about this is complicated.” I went back to my desk feeling that neither of them had given the matter the attention it deserved.
That evening, I decided to observe Mr Whiskers without interfering. I didn’t tell Pandora or John what I was doing because I knew exactly how that conversation would go. I settled into the living room with a book, positioned myself where I could see the hallway, and waited. For the first twenty minutes, nothing happened. Mr Whiskers slept on the couch, Pandora worked on a drawing at the kitchen table, and John watched something on his laptop with his headphones on. Then Pandora got up to make tea. She removed the blue hair tie from her ponytail, set it beside her notebook, and walked into the kitchen. Mr Whiskers opened one eye. He waited until she was out of sight, climbed onto the chair, and reached across the table with one paw. Within seconds, the hair tie was on the floor. He jumped down after it, picked it up in his mouth, and disappeared into the hallway.
I followed him as quietly as I could, which wasn’t particularly quietly because the floorboard outside our bedroom makes a noise like an elderly man complaining about his knees. Mr Whiskers stopped, looked back at me, and immediately increased his pace. By the time I reached the bedroom, he had vanished beneath the bed. I got down on my hands and knees and peered underneath. There he was, sitting beside a small collection of objects that looked suspiciously familiar. I could see at least six hair ties, one of Pandora’s missing pens, a bottle cap, two toy mice, and a sock I had been blaming the washing machine for eating since September. Mr Whiskers looked directly at me with the blue hair tie hanging from his mouth. For a moment, neither of us moved. Then he dropped it onto the pile and placed one paw over it, as though he had just acquired the last piece of an extremely valuable collection.
I called for Pandora. She came into the bedroom, found me lying on the floor with my head under the bed, and asked whether I’d lost something. I told her I’d found something, which was considerably more important. She crouched beside me, looked underneath, and started laughing. John appeared in the doorway a moment later, drawn by the commotion, and wanted to know why we were both on the floor. I pointed toward the evidence. He took one look and said, “Well, there’s your missing inventory.” Pandora reached beneath the bed and began retrieving hair ties while Mr Whiskers watched in obvious disapproval. Every time she pulled another one out, the cat moved closer, until he was sitting directly in front of her hand like a tiny security guard attempting to prevent an unauthorized withdrawal.
The real trouble started when Pandora collected the last of the hair ties and placed them on the dresser. Mr Whiskers climbed out from under the bed, sat at her feet, and complained loudly. Pandora told him those weren’t his toys. He complained again. John suggested that we should probably buy him something he was actually allowed to play with, preferably before he started stealing our wallets. I pointed out that he already had a basket full of toys in the living room. John said that was precisely why the hair ties were so appealing. “They’re forbidden,” he explained. “You can’t expect him to respect a toy that comes with permission.” I didn’t have a good response to that, partly because Mr Whiskers had begun staring at the dresser with the concentration of a professional safecracker.
Pandora solved the immediate problem by putting the recovered hair ties into a small lidded container and giving Mr Whiskers one of his actual toy mice. He sniffed the mouse, pushed it aside, and looked back at the dresser. I found this reaction insulting on behalf of everyone who had ever spent money buying that cat something nice. Pandora, meanwhile, was delighted to have her missing things back. She even found the little silver pen she’d been searching for all week. John picked up my missing sock and asked whether I wanted to add it to the official evidence log. I told him I hadn’t been keeping an evidence log. He looked at the notebook I’d brought into the bedroom, which contained a list of hair tie colors and locations, and raised an eyebrow. I explained that those were observations, not evidence. He said he was glad we’d cleared that up.
I thought the matter was settled until later that night, when I heard a faint scraping noise coming from the bedroom. Pandora was brushing her teeth, John was in the living room, and Mr Whiskers was nowhere to be seen. I followed the sound and found him standing on the dresser, pawing at the lid of the new container. He had somehow managed to drag it several inches toward the edge. I stood in the doorway watching him work, impressed despite myself. When he noticed me, he froze with one paw resting on the lid. I told him I knew what he was doing. He blinked once, slowly, then pushed the container another inch. I moved it into a drawer and shut it. Mr Whiskers stared at the drawer, then at me, and walked out of the room without making a sound. I didn’t like how calmly he accepted defeat.
The next morning, I found one of my shoelaces stretched across the kitchen floor. It was still attached to the shoe, which Mr Whiskers had apparently dragged halfway out of the closet. Pandora took one look and started laughing before I could explain what had happened. John said the cat was expanding his business interests now that the hair tie market had collapsed. I stood there holding my shoe, wondering how an animal that sleeps sixteen hours a day could create so much work for the rest of us. Pandora kissed me on the cheek, retrieved her coffee, and told me not to turn it into another investigation. I promised I wouldn’t. Then Mr Whiskers walked past carrying the other shoelace in his mouth, and I realized that my promise might have been premature. He’d lost access to the hair ties, but he’d already found a replacement. I was beginning to understand why Pandora kept buying new ones. The cat wasn’t stealing them because he needed them. He was stealing them because, in this household, he could.
