I Know I Saw Pandora’s Mug Yesterday Morning

I was standing in the kitchen yesterday morning, waiting for the coffee maker to finish its usual impression of a machine struggling to stay alive, when I noticed something missing. Pandora’s favorite mug wasn’t hanging on its hook beside the cabinet. Now, I realize that a missing coffee mug isn’t exactly the sort of thing that should bring a household to a standstill. We have an entire cabinet full of mugs, including several that nobody remembers buying and one that John Mercer insists he won at a bowling tournament despite having no recollection of ever going bowling. But Pandora’s mug is different. It’s the one she uses almost every morning, the one with the slightly chipped handle that she refuses to replace because, according to her, it has character. I know I saw it hanging there the previous morning. I’m certain of it. Or at least I was certain until I started thinking about how often I’ve been certain of things that turned out to be completely wrong.

I checked the dishwasher first, which seemed like the sensible place to begin. There were two plates, a fork, and a plastic container that had somehow survived three washing cycles without getting completely clean. No mug. I opened the cabinet, moved a few things around, and checked behind the coffee filters. Still nothing. I even looked in the sink, although I could see perfectly well from where I was standing that it wasn’t there. That’s when John Mercer wandered into the kitchen wearing an old T-shirt and the expression of a man who hadn’t yet agreed to participate in the day. He poured himself some coffee, took one look at me, and asked why I was examining the cabinets like somebody had stolen the silverware. I explained that Pandora’s mug was missing. He glanced at the empty hook, shrugged, and said, “Maybe she’s using it.” I told him that was an awfully convenient explanation, considering she wasn’t even in the kitchen. He stared at me for a moment before saying, “Hal, that’s generally how people take mugs out of kitchens.”

I didn’t appreciate his tone, although I couldn’t immediately find anything wrong with his argument. Pandora was upstairs getting ready for work, so I decided to ask her when she came down. In the meantime, I tried to remember the last time I’d actually seen the mug. I remembered it hanging on the hook yesterday morning. I remembered Pandora making tea after dinner. I remembered John complaining that we’d run out of the good biscuits, which turned into a fifteen-minute discussion about whether biscuits were actually cookies. What I couldn’t remember was Pandora putting her mug away. That bothered me more than it should have. I have a reasonably good memory for things that don’t matter. I can tell you which cabinet contains the batteries, where John keeps his emergency snacks, and exactly how many times Mr Whiskers has knocked the television remote behind the couch this month. Yet somehow, an entire coffee mug had disappeared without leaving a single useful clue.

Mr Whiskers appeared just as I was considering whether to inspect the trash. He walked into the kitchen, stretched his front paws against the cabinet, and looked up at me with the calm confidence of an animal who has never paid rent and never intends to. I asked him if he’d seen Pandora’s mug. He blinked. I asked whether he’d been on the counter again. He sat down and began washing his face, which struck me as a suspiciously deliberate attempt to avoid answering. John, who was still standing nearby with his coffee, suggested that questioning the cat might not be the best use of my morning. I told him that Mr Whiskers had a documented history of interfering with household objects. John reminded me that the cat also had a documented history of sleeping eighteen hours a day. “He’s got plenty of time to plan things,” I said. John took his coffee into the living room without responding.

Pandora came downstairs a few minutes later, carrying her work bag and looking for her keys. I asked whether she’d seen her mug. She gave me a puzzled look and said she thought she’d left it in the kitchen. When I told her it wasn’t there, she looked at the empty hook and said, “That’s strange.” Those two words were all the encouragement I needed. I’d been prepared for her to tell me she’d taken it upstairs or left it in the dishwasher, but she seemed just as surprised as I was. I asked whether she’d used it after dinner. She said she probably had, although she couldn’t remember exactly where she’d put it. Then she found her keys beneath a stack of mail, kissed me goodbye, and headed out the door. I stood there thinking about how casually she’d accepted the disappearance of an object she used every day. I wasn’t accusing her of anything. I just thought a little more curiosity would have been appropriate.

By the time John came back for a second cup of coffee, I’d developed three possible explanations. The first was that Pandora had put the mug somewhere unusual while distracted. The second was that John had borrowed it and forgotten. The third involved Mr Whiskers, although I hadn’t worked out how a cat could move a ceramic mug without making a considerable amount of noise. I presented these possibilities to John while he searched the refrigerator for something to eat. He listened patiently, then asked whether I’d checked the dining room. I told him I hadn’t because Pandora usually drank her tea in the living room. He looked at me over the refrigerator door and said, “So you’ve ruled out the dining room because she doesn’t usually go there?” I admitted that sounded less convincing when he put it that way. He took a yogurt from the fridge and told me to let him know when the investigation reached the garage.

I checked the dining room. The mug wasn’t there, but I did find a pen I’d been looking for since last Thursday and a receipt that explained why our grocery bill had been so high. Apparently, I’d bought three jars of olives during a sale and then forgotten about them. I considered that a useful discovery, although it didn’t help with the mug. From there I moved into the living room, where I examined the side tables, the bookshelf, and the space behind the couch. Mr Whiskers followed me, which I initially interpreted as cooperation. Then I realized he was waiting for me to move the cushions so he could retrieve a toy mouse. He watched while I reached into the gap, pulled out the mouse, and placed it on the floor. He immediately carried it away without so much as a thank-you. I’d been assisting his investigation, not the other way around.

Around lunchtime, Mrs Jenkins stopped by to return a small container Pandora had lent her. She’s our neighbor, and she’s one of those people who can turn a simple exchange at the front door into a pleasant twenty-minute conversation. I mentioned the missing mug while we were talking. She asked what it looked like, and I described the chipped handle and the little blue flowers around the rim. She thought for a moment, then said she hadn’t seen it. She did, however, remember seeing Mr Whiskers sitting in our front window the previous afternoon, looking particularly pleased with himself. I thanked her for the information, although I wasn’t sure what to do with it. Mrs Jenkins smiled and said, “You know, Hal, sometimes things are exactly where we leave them. We just forget where that was.” I told her that was certainly possible. Then I spent the next ten minutes wondering whether she’d meant something specific by it.

Karen called me at work later that afternoon about a question we’d been discussing earlier in the week. Once we’d sorted that out, I mentioned the mug. She laughed and asked whether I’d checked the dishwasher. When I told her I’d already checked it, she suggested the refrigerator. I asked why Pandora would put a mug in the refrigerator. Karen said she didn’t know, but she’d once found her television remote in a bag of groceries. I couldn’t argue with that. Before hanging up, she told me to let her know how the mystery ended because she was now invested in it. I suspected she was making fun of me, but I appreciated having somebody take an interest. Besides, I hadn’t checked the refrigerator thoroughly. I’d looked inside it several times that morning, but looking for milk isn’t quite the same as looking for a missing mug.

When I got home, I went straight to the kitchen. John was preparing dinner, and Pandora was sitting at the table sorting through some paperwork. I opened the refrigerator and examined every shelf. Nothing. I checked the freezer too, because at that point I figured I might as well be thorough. Pandora asked what I was doing. I told her Karen had suggested checking the refrigerator for her mug. She looked at John, who looked at me, and they both started laughing. I explained that people occasionally put things in strange places without realizing it. Pandora agreed, although she was still smiling. Then she asked whether I’d checked the microwave. I told her I hadn’t, because nobody had mentioned using the microwave. She gave me a look that suggested I was missing something obvious and said, “Hal, you heated up my tea yesterday morning.”

That’s when a rather unpleasant memory began working its way back into my head. Yesterday morning, Pandora had been running late and asked me to warm her tea while she finished getting ready. I’d taken her mug, placed it in the microwave, and set the timer for thirty seconds. I remembered doing that. What I didn’t remember was taking it back out. I turned toward the microwave, which was sitting less than three feet from where I’d spent most of the morning conducting my investigation. John stopped chopping vegetables. Pandora folded her arms. Even Mr Whiskers seemed interested, although that might have been because John had just opened a packet of chicken. I pressed the microwave’s door button, and there it was. Pandora’s favorite mug, complete with its chipped handle and little blue flowers, sitting exactly where I’d left it the previous morning.

For a few seconds, nobody said anything. Then John started laughing so hard he had to put down the knife. Pandora walked over, looked inside the microwave, and asked whether I wanted her to notify the authorities that the missing property had been recovered. I told her that wouldn’t be necessary. She asked how long I’d been looking for it. I said, “On and off.” John, who had witnessed most of the morning’s activities, made a noise that suggested he strongly disagreed with my description. Pandora took the mug out, inspected the contents, and informed me that I’d managed to leave half a cup of tea in the microwave for more than twenty-four hours. I pointed out that at least we’d found it before it developed a personality. She said that if it had developed one, it probably would have been more observant than I was.

I tried to defend myself by explaining that the mug’s absence from its usual hook had been a legitimate mystery. John said it had only become a mystery because I’d forgotten what I’d done with it. I told him there was an important distinction between those two things, although I couldn’t explain what it was. Pandora rinsed the mug and put it in the dishwasher, still smiling to herself. Mr Whiskers, meanwhile, had positioned himself beside the microwave and was staring at the empty space where the mug had been. I watched him for a moment and wondered whether he’d known it was there all along. He’d certainly spent enough time wandering around the kitchen while I searched. Then he reached up and tapped the microwave door with one paw. John saw it too. “Look at that,” he said. “Even the cat knew where to check.”

I would like to say that I accepted the situation gracefully, laughed at myself, and moved on with my evening. What actually happened was that I spent several minutes explaining how easy it is to overlook something when you’re concentrating on a particular set of possibilities. Pandora listened, nodded, and asked whether I’d like her to put a little reminder on the microwave next time. John suggested a sign that said, “Check Here Before Questioning the Neighbors.” I told him that wasn’t necessary either. Later that night, after everyone had gone to bed, I walked through the kitchen and glanced at the microwave one last time. Mr Whiskers was sitting on the counter beside it, looking at me with that familiar expression of quiet feline superiority. I gave him a scratch behind the ears and told him he could have mentioned something earlier. He yawned, jumped down, and wandered off. I suppose that’s fair. If I’d been watching a grown man spend an entire day searching for a mug he’d put in the microwave himself, I probably wouldn’t have interrupted the entertainment either.

Related Posts